Sounds Like Weird
This is a mirror of Stephen Goldin’s pages from SFF.net about Marion Zimmer Bradley. More notes here. Jump to deposition 2. The third deposition has never been made available online.
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
2 FOR THE COUNTY OF ALAMEDA
3 —o0o—
4 KEN SMITH, )
)
5 Plaintiff, )
)
6 vs. ) No. 778220-2
)
7 MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, ELISABETH )
WATERS, and DOES 1 through 10, )
8 )
Defendants. )
9 __________________________________)
10
11
12
13
14 DEPOSITION OF
15 MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY
16 _________________________________
17 Monday, August 10, 1998
18
19
20 SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES
1254 Leavenworth Street
21 San Francisco, California 94109
(415) 771-1988
22
23
24 REPORTED BY: JANINE P. BRANCO, CSR No. 10372
25
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
1
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 I N D E X
2 EXAMINATION BY: PAGE
3 MR. DOLAN 4
4 —o0o—
5 E X H I B I T S
6 PLAINTIFFS’ PAGE
7 1 2-page 7-29-98 “NOTICE OF TAKING 4
DEPOSITION OF DEFENDANT MARION
8 ZIMMER BRADLEY.”
9 2 2-page undated document entitled 24
“The Loyal Opposition.”
10
3 19-page 7-22-89 “BERKELEY POLICE 57
11 DEPARTMENT UNIVERSAL REPORT FORM.”
12 —o0o—
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
2
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 BE IT REMEMBERED THAT, pursuant to Notice of
2 Taking Deposition and on Monday, August 10, 1998,
3 commencing at the hour of 11:01 a.m. thereof, at 2121
4 Russell Street, Berkeley, California, before me,
5 JANINE P. BRANCO, a Certified Shorthand Reporter of the
6 State of California, personally appeared
7 MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY
8 a Defendant herein, called as a witness by the
9 Plaintiffs, having been by me first duly sworn, was
10 examined and testified hereinafter as set forth.
11 —o0o—
12 APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL
13 For the Plaintiffs Ken Smith and Mary Mason
THE LAW OFFICES OF CHRISTOPHER B. DOLAN
14 655 Montgomery Street, 16th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94111
15 By: CHRISTOPHER C. DOLAN and SCOTT BONAGOFSKY,
Attorneys at Law
16
For the Defendant Marion Zimmer Bradley
17 CAUDLE, WELCH, UMIPEG & BOVEE
1390 Willow Pass Road, Suite 200
18 Concord, CA 94520
By: M. HENRY WALKER, Attorney at Law
19
For the Defendant Elisabeth Waters
20 HAIMS, JOHNSON, MacGOWAN & McINERNEY
490 Grand Avenue
21 Oakland, CA 94610
By: LAWRENCE A. BAKER, Attorney at Law
22
ALSO PRESENT:
23
MARY MASON
24 BELLE ROMERO
25 —o0o—
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
3
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 P R O C E E D I N G S
2 MR. DOLAN: This will be the first exhibit.
3 (Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 1 was marked for
4 identification.)
5 EXAMINATION BY MR. DOLAN
6 Q. Please state your full name for the record.
7 A. Marion Zimmer Bradley.
8 Q. Ms. Bradley, my name is Christopher Dolan.
9 I’m an attorney who represents Kenneth Smith in this
10 case, and Mary Mason currently in this case.
11 I am here today to take your deposition. You
12 understand that?
13 A. Yes, I do.
14 Q. I am going to go through some of the rules of
15 a deposition.
16 Have you ever had your deposition taken
17 before?
18 A. My lawyer went over it with me the other day.
19 Q. Okay. Have you ever had your deposition
20 taken before?
21 A. No.
22 Q. I’m going to go over those rules just because
23 I need to make sure that we’re all clear on them.
24 But before I do so, do you know what day it
25 is today?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
4
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. I believe it is Monday.
2 Q. Okay. Do you know what month it is?
3 A. I think it is — it’s either July or August.
4 I do tend to lose track since the kids are out of
5 school.
6 Q. I understand.
7 Do you know where we are today, what the
8 address of this place is?
9 A. I don’t think I know the street address, but
10 it’s between Telegraph and Shattuck on Russell.
11 Q. And what are your children’s names?
12 A. My oldest son’s name is David Bradley. My
13 second son is named Patrick Russell Breen. And my
14 third, youngest daughter’s name is Laura Evelyn Dorothy
15 Breen.
16 Q. And what was your maiden name?
17 A. Marion Eleanor Zimmer.
18 Q. The rules of the deposition are as follows:
19 The first rule of a deposition is that everything we do
20 here is orally, so therefore the court reporter must
21 have oral statements made by all the people in
22 attendance today.
23 A. In other words, I say yes instead of nodding.
24 Q. Please.
25 A. Thank you.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
5
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Instead of using movements or hand gestures
2 or anything we may do in normal conversation, we need
3 full and complete English words. “Uh-huh” and “huh-uh”
4 don’t translate well.
5 A. I say “yes” or “no” or “maybe,” “I don’t
6 know.”
7 Q. Thank you.
8 The other rule of a deposition is we need to
9 let one person finish talking before the other one
10 begins because the court reporter can only take the
11 writing of one person at a time. So if you will wait
12 until I finish speaking before you begin speaking, I
13 will afford you the same courtesy.
14 A. I’ve been a school teacher. I know that. I
15 always try to get the kids to finish talking before —
16 talking before the next one starts.
17 Q. Very good.
18 The other thing is I don’t want you to guess
19 or speculate as to anything, but I am entitled to your
20 very best recollection.
21 A. If I don’t know the answer, I will just say
22 “I don’t remember.”
23 Q. You have to let me finish speaking before you
24 begin speaking. That’s the rule we just went over that
25 school teachers follow. Okay?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
6
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. Yes; I’ll try.
2 Q. So I don’t want you to guess or speculate,
3 but I am entitled to an estimate or an approximation.
4 So if you can’t remember something exactly, I am
5 entitled to your best estimate, however small it may be,
6 your recollection, so long as it’s not a guess.
7 The difference between the two can be
8 summarized as follows: We’re sitting at a table. I may
9 ask you the length of this table, and although you have
10 not measured it, you might be able to estimate it.
11 A. I would say it’s about eight feet.
12 Q. If I were to ask you the length of the
13 conference room table in my office, that would be a
14 guess because you have not been there.
15 A. I would just say I don’t know.
16 Q. Very good.
17 A. Thank you very much.
18 Q. If you do not understand a question that I
19 ask of you, I’ll ask that you please have me rephrase it
20 because I’m not here to trick you today. I want to make
21 sure that you completely understand before you answer.
22 All right?
23 A. Thank you. Yes, I understand.
24 Q. Are you under the influence of any
25 medications today?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
7
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. Well, I have taken insulin, which I am
2 steadily on for diabetes; and I am steadily under the
3 influence of the antidepressant Amipromene, which I take
4 one every night.
5 Q. Okay. And are you under the influence of any
6 other medication within the last 24 hours?
7 A. None whatsoever.
8 Q. Are either —
9 A. Except that I’m wearing a patch of….
10 Q. Nitroglycerin?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. Do any of the medications that you have just
13 described for me impair your ability to recall events?
14 A. I don’t believe so.
15 Q. At the end of your deposition, when it
16 concludes, you will have the opportunity to review and
17 read this deposition and make any changes that you feel
18 are appropriate or necessary.
19 A. Thank you.
20 Q. I must caution you, however, that if you make
21 substantive changes to your deposition, I have the right
22 to comment to the jury that you have changed or altered
23 your testimony. So we’d like to get your best testimony
24 today.
25 A. I’ll try.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
8
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. In that regard, if you think, geez, I need to
2 change something as we sit here, please let us know so
3 we can make those changes now. Okay?
4 A. In other words, have my second thoughts not a
5 month or a week from now.
6 Q. You’re entitled to have them whenever you
7 have them. I’m just letting you know there will be
8 repercussions.
9 A. It’s most convenient to have them right now.
10 Q. Please.
11 A. All right. I’ll do my best.
12 Q. You’re entitled to take a break anytime you
13 need to. We have a very limited time because we’re
14 doing this in limited amounts of time because of your
15 medical condition, so I would request if you need a
16 break, let us know. We’re not here to inconvenience you
17 or harm you in any way. Okay?
18 A. Thank you.
19 Q. However, I must caution you that if there is
20 a question pending, meaning you’ve got a question asked
21 and not answered, and you request a break before
22 answering it, I may place on the record that you are
23 breaking on a pending question, and I may draw an
24 inference at the time of trial that you have been
25 coached on your answer by your lawyer during that break.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
9
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 You are entitled to still do so, I’m just merely
2 advising you beforehand there may be re —
3 A. In other words, it’s okay to do it, but you
4 have to know about it.
5 Q. That’s fine. Or if you do ask for a break
6 after I’ve asked a question and you have not given an
7 answer, I may ask a jury to draw an inference that you
8 were coached during the break. Okay?
9 A. Uh-huh.
10 Q. Can you identify the woman to my right
11 (indicating)?
12 A. No. I don’t know her at all.
13 Q. Have you ever seen her before?
14 A. Not to my knowledge or belief.
15 Q. Do you have any idea or recollection who she
16 is?
17 A. No; I’m afraid not.
18 MR. DOLAN: Let the record reflect I pointed
19 to Mary Mason.
20 Q. Are you currently residing with Elisabeth
21 Waters at this residence?
22 A. Yes, I am.
23 No, not at this one. At the one over an Rose
24 or whatever that street it is. Ashby and Grove. No
25 Prince and Fulton.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
10
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Do you have a residence on Prince Street?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. Do you know the address of that residence?
4 A. 2221.
5 Q. How long have you been a resident in the home
6 where we are now?
7 A. Not at all. I have just bought the place,
8 and I believe we are not going to be able to keep it.
9 Q. When did you purchase this place?
10 A. Within the last month.
11 Q. So you’re not living here at all?
12 A. No.
13 Q. Where are you living?
14 A. Over in the house at Ashby — Prince and
15 Fulton.
16 Q. Prince and Fulton?
17 A. Yes; where I lived for the last 30 years.
18 Q. Do you know why we’re having your deposition
19 here today?
20 A. I believe it is because it was more
21 convenient to come over here, but I’m not really
22 certain.
23 Q. If at any time during this deposition you
24 feel you’re becoming unable to answer questions clearly
25 because of anything medical or psychological, we have to
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
11
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 ask that you let us know that so that we can try to make
2 sure we’re getting testimony that could be credible in
3 court.
4 A. Will do so.
5 Q. Do you understand that although we’re in your
6 living room of this vacant house today that this
7 particular deposition has the same force and effect as
8 if it were being taken in front of a judge and jury?
9 A. Yes, I do.
10 Q. And you have sworn to tell the truth under
11 penalty of perjury?
12 A. Yes, I have.
13 Q. I’m going to be asking you some very
14 uncomfortable questions today, and I apologize for doing
15 that in advance. This is an uncomfortable case.
16 A. Well, this is the law.
17 Q. Okay. I just want you to know that there is
18 nothing personal in my questions to you today. And if
19 they cause you discomfort, I apologize, but it is my job
20 on behalf of my client to do the hard job of asking
21 these questions.
22 A. Thank you.
23 Q. When did you first become aware that your
24 husband had been sexually involved with boys under the
25 age of 18 years old?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
12
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. I have —
2 MR. WALKER: Objection. That lacks
3 foundation.
4 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer.
5 A. I was about to say that I had read some
6 things that he had written on the subject, but
7 unfortunately, I believed from the very beginning that
8 it was a sort of an intellectual position, a sort of a
9 feeling that it was something that was talked about in
10 Greek literature and was sort of a testing position.
11 Q. Did you know that he had a relationship with
12[Victim X]?
13 A. I became aware of it, yes.
14 Q. When did you become aware of it?
15 A. About that time.
16 Q. What time?
17 A. Shortly after we were married. At that time
18 I treated [Victim X] like one of my own children. He and my
19 son David used to go swimming together and such.
20 Q. And to your knowledge, how old was [Victim X] when
21 your husband was having a sexual relationship with him?
22 A. I think he was —
23 MR. WALKER: Objection. That lacks
24 foundation. She never testified she was aware they had
25 a sexual relationship.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
13
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer.
2 A. I think he was about 14 or possibly 15. I’m
3 not certain.
4 Q. Were you aware that your husband had a sexual
5 relationship with [Victim X] when he was below the age
6 of 18?
7 A. Yes, I was.
8 Q. Did you know that about the time you were
9 married to your husband?
10 A. Shortly afterward. It was quite shocking to
11 me.
12 Q. How did you find that out?
13 A. I believe he mentioned it.
14 Q. Who mentioned it?
15 A. Walter.
16 Q. And what did he tell you?
17 A. Well, he told me that he and [Victim X] were
18 sleeping together. And I said that I had believed that
19 was an intellectual position. He told me it was not. I
20 was very upset.
21 Q. So back in the 1960s you knew that it was not
22 just an intellectual position for Walter; correct?
23 A. I knew that intellectually. I didn’t have
24 any physical awareness of it.
25 Q. Didn’t Walter tell you that he was sleeping
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
14
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 with [Victim X]?
2 A. He did. But you know how it is when you’re
3 told something, and everything people say needs people
4 to say it and one to hear it. At that time I don’t
5 think I was emotionally or intellectually capable of
6 hearing it.
7 Q. But you do recall hearing it?
8 A. Yes, I do recall hearing it.
9 Q. What else did Walter tell you on the subject
10 of his relationship with [Victim X]?
11 A. I know that he gave him a bicycle.
12 Q. When did he give him the bicycle?
13 A. It was before I had come to live with him.
14 Q. Do you know where [Victim X] lives now?
15 A. I have not seen or heard of [Victim X] since he was
16 — since about three years after we were married. I
17 presume he is still alive somewhere, but, that is, I
18 have not heard anything to the contrary.
19 Q. Did Walter ever discuss with you at length
20 the various sexual activities that he would undertake
21 with [Victim X]?
22 A. No.
23 Q. Did Walter ever tell you that he thought it
24 was a mutually desired situation between [Victim X] and
25 himself?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
15
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. I had read that in his book.
2 Q. Which book?
3 A. He wrote a book called “Greek Love” under the
4 name of John Eglington.
5 Q. And you reviewed some of the manuscripts of
6 that book before it was published?
7 A. Yes, I did.
8 Q. And did you contribute by doing proofreading?
9 A. I did proofreading, yes.
10 Q. Did you do some editorial work on that book?
11 A. I attempted to, but I found out afterward
12 that everything I had done had been thrown out by the
13 publisher, Robert Bashno (phonetic).
14 Q. But you did attempt to make some editorial
15 changes to that book as it was being written?
16 A. Yes, I did.
17 Q. And at that time you were also aware that he
18 had a sexual relationship with [Victim X]?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Did you ever talk to [Victim X]’s mother about —
21 A. No.
22 Q. You have to let me finish.
23 A. Sorry.
24 Q. Did you ever talk to [Victim X]’s mother about the
25 sexual relationship between Walter and [Victim X]?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
16
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. No.
2 Q. Did you ever talk to the police about a
3 sexual relationship between Walter and [Victim X]?
4 A. I don’t remember. I know that I talked to a
5 lawyer Walter had at the time.
6 Q. And who was that lawyer?
7 A. I don’t remember her name. She was a lady.
8 Q. And what did you and the lawyer talk about?
9 A. About his book.
10 Q. Can you tell me the context of your
11 conversation, please?
12 A. Largely that I had heard that [mother of Victim X] had said
13 that she had nothing to complain about in [Victim X]’s
14 relationship with Walter. And I thought that, well,
15 because [Victim X] would come — he had been accused of
16 stealing milk out of refrigerators, and he would come to
17 dinner with us, and he obviously hadn’t eaten for a long
18 time.
19 Q. How did you hear that [mother of Victim X] had no
20 complaints about the sexual relationship between your
21 husband and her minor child?
22 A. She told me.
23 Q. So you did speak with her about this?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And when did you speak with her about this?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
17
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. It was, as I say, shortly after we were
2 married.
3 Q. And what was the nature of the conversation
4 with [mother of Victim X] regarding your husband’s sexual
5 interactions with her son?
6 A. I don’t remember that we spent any time on
7 it. Mostly she was telling me that I was not a good
8 writer, that I was a commercial hack, and that she was a
9 great and artistic poet. I told her that at least I
10 could feed my kids on what I did, and that if she had
11 kids to feed, she’d probably do it too or — that is,
12 write commercially.
13 Q. What about the subject matter between the sex
14 of your husband and her son did you discuss that led you
15 to believe that she had no complaint about this sexual
16 relationship?
17 A. I think what she said almost exactly was “I
18 find nothing to complain about,” but I can’t remember
19 exactly. That was, I think, about 25 or 30 years ago.
20 Q. Was this sex occurring ever in your home?
21 A. Not that I —
22 No, not to my knowledge.
23 Q. Was [Victim X] ever spending the night at your
24 home?
25 A. Yes; but he slept with my older son.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
18
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Did you ever hear a report from Moira [Victim X]
2 was found in Walter’s bed?
3 A. No, I didn’t. I don’t think Moira knew [Victim X]
4 from Adams or Fox.
5 MR. WALKER: I would like to remind you here
6 of an agreement we had.
7 MR. DOLAN: I know about it. I’m not going
8 there.
9 MR. WALKER: Okay.
10 MR. DOLAN: I’m going to be very respectful
11 of that. I’m going to be very respectful of her.
12 MR. WALKER: Okay.
13 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever talk to [Victim X]
14 about the sexual relationship between [Victim X] and Walter?
15 A. Not to my memory, no.
16 Q. Did you ever report this sexual relationship
17 between your husband and a minor child to the police?
18 A. Not to my knowledge.
19 Q. Can you tell me, were you aware that it was
20 illegal for your husband to be having sex with a minor
21 child?
22 A. No, I was not. I believed at that time —
23 I know you told me not to volunteer anything.
24 But I did seriously believe at that time that
25 a teenage boy was old enough to make his own judgments
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
19
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 in this matter. They let a girl get married when she’s
2 12, and I thought that a boy of 14 or 15 would certainly
3 be old enough.
4 Q. So it was your personal opinion that a boy of
5 14 to 15 years old was old enough to make decisions
6 about having sex with a 50-year-old man?
7 A. Yes, I was. I believe so.
8 He was not 50 at the time.
9 Q. How old was he?
10 A. 30.
11 He and I were the same age. I’ve been told
12 since that he was two years older than that, but I
13 believe that that was what his mother told him.
14 Q. Did you have any other discussions with
15 [mother of Victim X] about the sexual relationship between
16 your husband and her minor child?
17 A. No.
18 Q. Did your husband ever pay any money to [mother of
19 Victim X], as far as you know, to settle any disputes
20 between her and himself regarding sex between himself
21 and her minor child?
22 A. No.
23 Q. When did your husband give a bicycle to this
24 child?
25 A. I think it was about three months before I
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
20
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 came to join him.
2 Q. Do you know where this woman lives now,
3 [mother of Victim X]?
4 A. No. I don’t even know if she’s still alive.
5 Q. Do you know if your husband ever wrote any
6 poems that he published about his sexual relationship
7 with [Victim X]?
8 A. I never saw them if he did.
9 Q. Okay.
10 A. I know that he translated some Italian work
11 on the subject because he had me help him with the
12 translation.
13 Q. Did you ever — strike that.
14 To your knowledge, was the subject of your
15 husband’s sexual relationship with [Victim X] the
16 basis for the “Boondoggle”?
17 A. Yes; I think so.
18 Q. Can you briefly describe for us your
19 understanding of what the “Boondoggle” was?
20 A. There was a young man up in — I think it was
21 in Washington, not D.C., up north in Washington, and he
22 wanted the — to be the recipient of what they call the
23 Big Pond Fund, which sent a man overseas to the
24 convention in England. Walter also had been nominated
25 for that. And Jack Sphere was — the other man was
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
21
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 afraid that Walter would get it, so he published this
2 thing about Walter being all of these things, a
3 pedophile, and guilty of this, that and the other, and
4 everything — everything up to and including the Civil
5 War.
6 Q. Did you ever publicly defend Walter in terms
7 of his not being a pedophile?
8 A. Yes, I did.
9 Q. And was that during the “Boondoggle”?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. Can you tell me why you would publicly state
12 that Walter was not a pedophile when you knew that he
13 had been having sex with a minor child?
14 A. Because, as I said, [Victim X] did not impress me
15 as a minor child. He was late in his teens, and I
16 considered him — I think he would have been old enough
17 to be married in this state legally, so I figured what
18 he did sexually was his own business.
19 Q. The “Boondoggle” was partly — the subject
20 matter was directed partly towards the sexual
21 relationship with [Victim X] and Walter Breen;
22 correct?
23 A. As far as I can remember, yes.
24 Q. And did you —
25 Was the existence of that sexual relationship
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
22
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 part of Walter’s defense in the “Boondoggle”?
2 A. As I say, it was a long time ago. I don’t
3 remember whether I denied it or whether I said that it
4 was nobody’s business.
5 Q. But you did one of the two, either denied it
6 or said it was nobody’s business?
7 A. That’s right.
8 Q. At what point do you personally believe that
9 it’s inappropriate to have sex with a minor child?
10 A. At this point I have no opinion on the
11 matter.
12 Q. Did you ever publish any documentation
13 regarding the “Boondoggle” in any of the fanzines?
14 A. Not that I remember.
15 Q. Did you ever publish anything in the fanzine
16 called “The Loyal Opposition”?
17 A. I don’t remember. I may have, but I….
18 Q. Did Bill Donaho publish something that you
19 considered to be a slander about you?
20 A. Yes, he did.
21 Q. And what was that?
22 A. Well, as far as I remember, there was a
23 cartoon. Bill Donaho is a big blowhard. The only time
24 I ever met him he was very rude to me, and I didn’t like
25 him.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
23
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. And what was the subject matter of the
2 cartoon that you felt was a slander of you?
3 A. It was a picture of some character standing
4 around saying, “Why don’t you two get started while I
5 make up the fire” or something. I don’t remember very
6 clearly.
7 Q. Was there anything that Bill Donaho said that
8 led you to believe that he was claiming you were a
9 person who could only drag Walter down to deeper depths
10 of depravity?
11 A. I have no idea.
12 Q. I’m going to show you a document that we’re
13 going to mark as Plaintiffs’ No. 2.
14 (Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 2 was marked for
15 identification.)
16 MR. DOLAN: Q. I’m going to ask you to look
17 at the first page of Plaintiffs’ 2. It’s a two-page
18 document from a fanzine entitled “The Loyal Opposition.”
19 A. Oh, yes. I vaguely remember.
20 Q. Would you look at Page 2 where your name
21 appears?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. Did you write these two paragraphs here? And
24 please take the time to read it, if that will be of help
25 to you.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
24
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. He’s lying in his teeth. The scandal’s so
2 unbelievable that I cannot repeat it here.
3 Q. What was the scandal?
4 A. It was —
5 Well, as I say, it was that cartoon
6 showing — showing David and me and Walter, and Walter
7 was supposedly saying, “Why don’t you two get started
8 while I get things locked up” or something of that sort.
9 Q. “Get started” referencing a sexual act?
10 A. I think that was implied.
11 Q. When you said “David,” are you talking about
12 your son?
13 A. My oldest son, yes.
14 Q. That was the item that you were thinking
15 could not be sent through the U.S. mail?
16 A. Something like that.
17 At that time I had been in — I believed very
18 firmly that obscene matter was not fit to be sent
19 through the mail. There had been a big scandal about
20 it.
21 Q. Have you yourself been arrested for sending
22 obscene things through the mail?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. When was that?
25 A. While I was living in Texas.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
25
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. And what was the documentation that you sent
2 through the mail that was — caused you to be arrested?
3 A. One that caused me to be arrested was a young
4 man with whom I had been corresponding for many years,
5 whose name was Dean Boggs, had asked me some
6 questions — having no brothers or sisters — about
7 female anatomy, and I drew him a picture to illustrate.
8 It was a picture that one might have found on the pages
9 of an anatomy or biology textbook.
10 Q. How old was Dean Boggs at the time that you
11 sent him this graphic drawing?
12 A. I think he and I were within a few weeks of
13 each other in age.
14 Q. How old were you?
15 A. I think I was about 32. It was the year
16 before I married Walter.
17 Q. Did you plead guilty to that charge?
18 A. Yes, I did.
19 Q. In what county of Texas was this?
20 A. I don’t remember. It was in the county — I
21 think it was up in a town called Rochester. And at the
22 time I was going to college in Abilene, and the hearing
23 was held there.
24 Q. Were there any other items that you had sent
25 through the mail that had likewise been intercepted?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
26
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. Not that I can remember.
2 MR. WALKER: I don’t think that she testified
3 that anything was intercepted.
4 MR. DOLAN: Q. Do you know how the mail was
5 found to be obscene by the authorities?
6 A. Personally I think they were — strike that.
7 I believe that they illegally examined some
8 of my letters.
9 Q. Okay. So, to your understanding, those
10 letters were intercepted by the post office?
11 A. I believe so.
12 At the time I believe that first-class mail
13 was supposed to be in violate. I think the matter was
14 still under question at the Supreme Court at that time.
15 Q. Was there any other mail that you know of
16 that was intercepted of yours around that time?
17 A. I believe they took a book that I had sent to
18 me from France. It was Vladimir Nabokov’s “Lolita,”
19 which was later judged to be quite permissible.
20 Q. It’s actually been put on Showtime and HBO
21 last week, as a matter of fact, with Jeremy Irons as the
22 leading man.
23 A. I saw the old James Mason version.
24 Q. Right.
25 If you look at this document in front of you
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
27
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 again, in the second paragraph it says in here, “Anyone
2 who defends Walter Breen is worse than Walter.” Do you
3 see where you’ve written that?
4 A. Where?
5 Q. Well, it’s actually in the —
6 A. Oh, yes.
7 Q. — third sentence.
8 A. I was quoting Bill Donaho.
9 Q. Were you at that time defending Walter Breen?
10 A. Yes, I was.
11 Q. And how were you defending Walter Breen?
12 A. By saying that whatever it was was nobody’s
13 business but his.
14 Q. And, to your knowledge, did you ever publicly
15 during that defense of Walter Breen state that it never
16 happened?
17 A. I don’t remember, but I don’t think so.
18 Q. Who’s [Johnny Doe 1]?
19 A. Oh, he’s a little kid who was living around
20 our property at that time.
21 Q. How old was [Johnny Doe 1]?
22 A. I think he was about 13, 14.
23 Q. To your knowledge, did your husband ever have
24 a sexual relationship with [Johnny Doe 1]?
25 A. I don’t know. At that time I believed Walter
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
28
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 was completely impotent.
2 Q. My question is not whether you believed
3 Walter was impotent, but did you ever receive any facts
4 or information that led you to believe that Walter was
5 having a sexual relationship with [Johnny Doe 1]?
6 A. No, I did not.
7 Q. Did your daughter ever report that [Johnny Doe 1] had
8 been found in Walter’s bed?
9 A. She did.
10 Q. Did you find that odd?
11 A. No. Walter had shared a bed with me on many
12 occasions perfectly innocently.
13 Q. You knew that Walter was a pedophile at that
14 time?
15 A. I knew it. Intellectually, yes, I knew it.
16 Q. And you knew that he was sharing a bed with a
17 13-year-old boy at that point; correct?
18 A. Yes. But, as I say, I believed Walter was
19 impotent and nothing that could bother anyone could
20 happen.
21 MR. WALKER: Now, when you say “sharing a
22 bed,” I think she was testifying about one occasion. I
23 don’t think —
24 THE WITNESS: Same occasions.
25 MR. WALKER: I don’t think you’ve asked —
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
29
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 MR. DOLAN: Sharing a bed one time or more
2 with a 13-year-old boy — we’re going to get into in
3 more detail here.
4 MR. WALKER: I just want to make sure the
5 record is clear what you’re asking her. Ask her a good
6 question, and she’ll give you the answer.
7 MR. DOLAN: My questions are good. I like my
8 questions.
9 THE WITNESS: I was starting —
10 MR. WALKER: You don’t have to answer. Let
11 him pose a question, and then you can answer.
12 THE WITNESS: All I was going to say is that
13 on one occasion I shared a house — I shared a bed with
14 about seven other people, but we were all having a party
15 overnight at the — I think it was up at the — what’s
16 the name? I’ve forgotten her name. I drew a blank.
17 The lady and her husband were hosting an overnight
18 party, and there were about 14 people there. And I
19 think about nine of us piled into bed together.
20 MR. DOLAN: Q. How many of those were
21 children?
22 A. Four or five, I think.
23 Q. So you’ve shared a bed with minor children
24 before too?
25 A. Well, they were all little girls.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
30
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. At the time were you aware that [Johnny Doe 1]
2 was in Walter’s bed on more than one occasion?
3 A. No, I was not.
4 Q. Did you make any attempts to adopt
5 [Johnny Doe 1]?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Through what agency did you attempt to adopt
8 [Johnny Doe 1]?
9 A. I think it was the Alameda County Children’s
10 Protective Services or something to that effect. It was
11 a long time ago, and I don’t really remember much about
12 it.
13 Q. Did you have to undergo any kind of
14 interviews or evaluation for the fitness of being
15 adoptive parents?
16 A. Yes. We went to a class for counseling for
17 adoptive parents.
18 Q. And at what time frame was this that you had
19 heard the report that [Johnny Doe 1] had been in
Walter’s
20 bed?
21 A. I don’t remember.
22 Q. Can you give me an estimate or approximation?
23 A. No; I really can’t. That was a long time
24 ago.
25 Q. Was it when you were living at 2221 Prince
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
31
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Street with Walter?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. Was it prior to your — you and Elisabeth
4 moving out of 2221 Prince Street?
5 A. I don’t remember.
6 Q. Was it in the 1980s?
7 A. It may well have been.
8 Q. Was it before Ken Smith’s molestation was
9 reported?
10 A. I never heard of Ken Smith. I mean, I’m told
11 now that I know who he was, but I don’t have any clear
12 memory of him.
13 Q. Do you recall the fact that Walter was
14 arrested for the molestation of Ken Smith?
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. Was the fact that Walter was in bed with
17 [Johnny Doe 1] known to you before Ken Smith was
arrested?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. Strike that. I’m going to ask the question
20 again.
21 Was the fact that Walter was in bed with
22 [Johnny Doe 1] known to you before Walter was arrested
for
23 the molestation of Ken Smith?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. Was the fact that Walter was in bed with
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
32
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 [Johnny Doe 1] known to you before you rented him the
2 premises known as the goldfish bowl?
3 A. No.
4 Q. So you found that out after you had rented
5 him the goldfish bowl?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. And were you aware that he was found in bed
8 with [Johnny Doe 1] at the goldfish bowl?
9 A. No.
10 Q. Where was he found in bed with [Johnny Doe 1]?
11 A. I don’t remember.
12 Q. Okay.
13 A. I thought of [Johnny Doe 1] as a little boy that
came
14 over the house, and he used to sit on my lap.
15 Q. Did you think [Johnny Doe 1] was of the age to make
16 decisions whether or not he could have a sexual
17 relationship with Walter?
18 A. I was sort of ambivalent about that. [Johnny Doe 1]
19 was like a stray cat that somebody put out on the
20 street, and I think he was surviving any way he could.
21 Q. That would include having sex with older men?
22 A. Probably.
23 MR. WALKER: Objection. Asks for
24 speculation.
25 MR. DOLAN: I just asked her —
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
33
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 MR. WALKER: I don’t think that that’s —
2 MR. BAKER: Argumentative.
3 MR. DOLAN: Did you get the answer?
4 THE REPORTER: Yes.
5 MR. DOLAN: Q. Was [Johnny Doe 1] surviving by
6 having sex with older men?
7 MR. BAKER: Argumentative.
8 THE WITNESS: I don’t know.
9 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever talk to [Johnny Doe 1]
10 [Johnny Doe 1]’s mother?
11 A. No.
12 Q. Did you ever talk to his parents at all about
13 this proposed adoption?
14 A. Yes. His mother came to see us on one
15 occasion, and she paid more attention to the cat than
16 she did [Johnny Doe 1]. She just said, “Oh, hello,
[Johnny Doe 1],” and
17 then she never looked at him or talked to him again.
18 Q. Did you talk to her at all?
19 A. Very little.
20 Q. So your testimony just given two seconds ago
21 that you didn’t speak to her was incorrect?
22 A. Yes; I spoke to her formally.
23 Q. Did you tell her that your husband and her
24 child had been in bed together?
25 A. No, I did not.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
34
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Why didn’t you?
2 A. It didn’t occur to me that it was important.
3 Q. Did you ever disclose to her that your
4 husband was a pedophile?
5 A. I never thought of him that way.
6 Q. Did you ever tell her that your husband had a
7 sexual relationship with a minor boy named [Victim X]?
8 A. No.
9 Q. Did you ever have any knowledge that your
10 husband had been arrested in Atlantic City for lewd and
11 lascivious acts with a minor?
12 A. No, I did not know that.
13 Q. Do you know who Kevin was in New York?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. Who was Kevin?
16 A. He was a young man. At that time there were
17 many multiple marriages, and at that time Walter and
18 Kevin formed a triangle. It went on only for a short
19 time.
20 Q. Okay. How old was Kevin?
21 A. I think he was 21 or 22.
22 Q. Let’s get back to [Johnny Doe 1] for a minute.
23 Did you ever have to fill out any paperwork
24 to adopt [Johnny Doe 1]?
25 A. I don’t remember.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
35
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Did you ever disclose to the Berkeley — or
2 strike that — the Alameda County Youth Authority, who
3 you think it was, that your husband was a pedophile?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Did you conceal that from them?
6 A. I didn’t think about it.
7 Q. Did the police ever investigate your
8 husband’s relationship with [Johnny Doe 1]?
9 A. No.
10 Q. To your knowledge, did the Berkeley Police
11 ever investigate your husband’s relationship with minor
12 children prior to this incident with Ken Smith?
13 A. Not that I know of.
14 Q. To your knowledge, did the police investigate
15 the issue surrounding the “Boondoggle”?
16 A. They did not.
17 Q. Did you ever tell your daughter that your
18 husband preferred young boys between the ages of 9 and
19 10?
20 A. I don’t think so.
21 Q. Can you deny that as you sit here today?
22 A. I don’t remember doing so.
23 Q. Okay. But you can’t deny it specifically
24 never happening?
25 A. Correct.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
36
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
2 MR. DOLAN: Q. You can answer.
3 A. No, I don’t remember any such thing.
4 Q. All right. If your daughter testified under
5 oath that you told her that your husband preferred boys
6 between the ages of 9 and 10, would you be able to deny
7 that conversation?
8 A. Yes.
9 MR. BAKER: Objection. Speculation.
10 MR. WALKER: And Counsel, we’ve already
11 talked about this.
12 MR. DOLAN: We talked about — we can step
13 outside if you want.
14 MR. WALKER: Let’s step outside.
15 MR. DOLAN: Pardon us.
16 (Mr. Dolan, Mr. Bonagofsky, Mr. Walker and
17 Mr. Baker exit and return.)
18 MR. DOLAN: Q. If your daughter were to
19 testify that you had spoken to her and told her that
20 Walter preferred sex with boys between the ages of 9 and
21 10, would you be able to deny that conversation ever
22 taking place?
23 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
24 Speculation.
25 MR. WALKER: I’ll join in the objection.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
37
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 MR. DOLAN: Q. You can answer.
2 A. I would say that I deny it absolutely.
3 Q. Okay. How many times did [Johnny Doe 1] stay
4 over at your house?
5 MR. WALKER: I think that lacks foundation.
6 I don’t think she testified that he stayed over.
7 MR. BAKER: Join.
8 THE WITNESS: I don’t remember.
9 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did [Johnny Doe 1] stay over at
10 your house?
11 A. I don’t remember.
12 Q. So you don’t know either way?
13 A. (Shakes head.)
14 Q. Is that a “Yes”?
15 A. I would say that I do not know.
16 Q. Okay. Whose [Johnny Doe 2]?
17 A. Oh, he’s some — he’s a neighbor up the
18 street.
19 Q. Does he still live up the street?
20 A. That was many years ago, but I think probably
21 he does.
22 Q. Okay. Do you know his mother’s name?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Do you know where up the street they lived
25 from you?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
38
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. No; just somewhere up the street.
2 Q. To your knowledge, was there ever any
3 accusation that Walter was having a sexual relationship
4 with [Johnny Doe 2]?
5 A. I never heard it if there was.
6 Q. Have you ever spoken to any of the parents of
7 any minor children, informed them that Walter would
8 never harm them?
9 A. I don’t remember.
10 Q. Have you ever told any of the parents of
11 minor children that Walter was not a pedophile?
12 A. I don’t remember the subject has ever come
13 up.
14 Q. So you don’t remember either way; correct?
15 A. Uh-huh, I don’t remember either way.
16 Q. How old was [Name A] when you began
17 having a sexual relationship with her?
18 MR. WALKER: Objection. Argumentative and
19 lacks foundation.
20 MR. DOLAN: I’ll rephrase.
21 Q. Did you ever have a sexual relationship with
22 [Name A]?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Did you ever participate in an orgy with
25 [Name A]?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
39
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. Depending on what you call….
2 Q. Did you ever participate in an orgy with
3 Elisabeth Waters, [Name A] and Philip Wang?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Was she ever present during a sexual act that
6 you were involved in with other people?
7 A. She might have been.
8 Q. Elisabeth Waters has testified to being
9 involved in an orgy with you and [Name A]. Do
10 you deny that ever took place?
11 A. I neither deny nor affirm it. I simply don’t
12 remember any such event.
13 Q. Did you ever have sexual relations with [Name A]–
15 MR. WALKER: Objection. That’s been asked
16 and answered.
17 MR. DOLAN: Q. — of any kind.
18 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
19 MR. DOLAN: Q. You can answer.
20 A. Not that I can remember.
21 I was riding once in a car with her, and she
22 kept putting her hand on my knee. And I shoved her hand
23 off my knee, and we hit the curb. We hit the curb and
24 blew a tire.
25 Q. Did [Name A] come to live with you?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
40
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. How old was she when she came to live with
3 you?
4 A. I think she was 18 or 19.
5 Q. How old was Elisabeth Waters when she came to
6 live with you?
7 A. 28.
8 MR. WALKER: Counsel, were you asking when
9 [Name A] came or when Elisabeth Waters came?
10 MR. DOLAN: Q. When Elisabeth Waters came
11 and lived with you, how old was she?
12 A. 28.
13 Q. Is she your cousin?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. And what is she, your first, second cousin,
16 what?
17 A. Ninth.
18 A friend of ours has a hobby doing genealogy,
19 and we looked it up and found out that we were cousins
20 in the ninth degree, that we had a common ancestor on
21 the Mayflower.
22 Q. Other than — well, strike that.
23 Did [Victim X] ever live with you?
24 A. No.
25 Q. Did he ever stay over at the house when you
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
41
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 were there with Walter?
2 A. I don’t remember.
3 Q. Did [Johnny Doe 1] ever live with you?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Did you ever have him stay over?
6 A. Wait. Excuse me. Strike that.
7 Yes, he did. He was downstairs in a room
8 between — that was one reason that we made him leave
9 was because we said he had to go to school and he had to
10 respect the girls’ privacy. We had a young friend
11 living with us then named [Jane Doe 1], and he was
always
12 popping into the girls’ room when they were dressing.
13 Q. Is that [Jane Doe 1] ?
14 A. No. That’s a girl called [Jane Doe 1]. She
15 was in my daughter’s second grade with her, and they
16 were in dancing class together.
17 Q. And she lived with you for a time period?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. Other than [Johnny Doe 1] living with you for a
20 time period, did any other minor children — young boys
21 live with you?
22 A. Let me think. Not that I can remember.
23 Q. Whose idea was it to adopt [Johnny Doe 1]?
24 A. As I remember, Walter and I were talking it
25 over together that he had become like a son in our
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
42
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 household and that why shouldn’t we try it.
2 Q. Did any members of the community oppose this
3 proposed adoption?
4 A. I don’t remember them opposing it.
5 Q. Do you know if there were any background
6 investigations done by the Alameda County Youth
7 Authority of you or your husband regarding this?
8 A. I don’t think so.
9 Q. Was Elisabeth Waters living at the house at
10 the time [Johnny Doe 1] was going to be adopted?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. Did you know of Walter’s pedophilic ways?
13 MR. WALKER: Lacks foundation.
14 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever know about
15 Walter’s pedophilic ways?
16 MR. BAKER: Objection. Lacks foundation.
17 Misstates her previous testimony.
18 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did Elisabeth Waters ever
19 come to you and raise any questions about Walter’s
20 behavior with young children?
21 A. Not until this thing came up with whoever it
22 was.
23 Q. With who?
24 A. I’m trying to remember. Some — they’ve
25 alleged some kid I wouldn’t know from Adam.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
43
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Ken Smith?
2 A. I think that may be the one.
3 Q. Sean Sullivan?
4 A. I don’t know. As I said, I have no memory of
5 any of it.
6 Q. Has anyone told you that you have memory
7 problems with certain areas of your memory?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. And who told you that?
10 A. My doctor.
11 Q. Which doctor?
12 A. My heart specialist. I can’t remember his
13 name at the moment.
14 Q. Do you know who Ian Studebaker is?
15 A. He’s my nephew.
16 Q. To your knowledge, did Ian Studebaker ever
17 complain that Walter had —
18 A. No.
19 Q. Did Tracy Blackstone ever complain about the
20 fact that Walter had inappropriately touched Ian?
21 A. Not to me.
22 Q. Do you know if she complained about it to
23 anyone else?
24 A. I have no idea.
25 Q. Did Tracy state that Ian couldn’t come over
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
44
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 to the house unless you or Elisabeth were there?
2 A. I don’t know. She made that statement about
3 her daughter Fiona.
4 Q. Okay. She told you she didn’t want Fiona
5 coming over to your home unless you or Elisabeth were
6 there?
7 A. That’s what she said.
8 Q. Did you ever ask her why?
9 A. No. I thought Tracy was just — well,
10 Tracy’s a funny person.
11 Q. What did Tracy say to you?
12 A. As far as I know, she just said — Tracy said
13 Fiona couldn’t come over here unless Elisabeth or I were
14 there. And I thought it was simply because we were all
15 coming in and out. There were quite a lot of people
16 around.
17 Q. To your knowledge, did Walter ever have
18 underage boys, meaning boys under the age of 18, in the
19 hot tub at your house at 2221 Prince Street?
20 A. Not to my knowledge.
21 Q. Did —
22 A. David was there sometimes.
23 Q. Did Elisabeth Waters ever discuss with you
24 any concerns that she had that Walter might have been
25 molesting [Johnny Doe 3]?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
45
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. No. I thought [Johnny Doe 3] was Moira’s
2 boyfriend.
3 Q. Did you ever insist to Elisabeth Waters that
4 Walter was incapable of molesting [Johnny Doe 3]?
5 A. I can’t remember, but it doesn’t sound like
6 the sort of thing I would say.
7 Q. Elisabeth Waters in her 10-8-89 diary, which
8 was given to the police, indicates the following:
9 Quote, “And I feel like a total idiot for not having
10 said anything back when I thought Walter was molesting
11 [Johnny Doe 3] ten years ago. I guess it was just
another
12 case of,” quote, “‘Don’t trust your own perceptions when
13 the adults are telling you you’re wrong.’
14 “Marion insisted that Walter was incapable of
15 it, and she was 22 years older than I and married, while
16 I was very ignorant about sex.”
17 Does that refresh your recollection at all as
18 to whether you had a conversation with Elisabeth Waters
19 about the molestation of —
20 A. If she says so, it probably happened.
21 Q. Okay. Do you have any —
22 Does that refresh your recollection about
23 that conversation?
24 A. No. I don’t remember the conversation at
25 all.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
46
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Having had that read to you, do you recall
2 telling Elisabeth that, that Walter would be incapable
3 of molesting [Johnny Doe 3]?
4 A. No, I don’t.
5 Q. Do you know if Walter was incapable of giving
6 oral sex to minor boys?
7 A. I have no idea. I know nothing at all about
8 oral sex. I broke up both my own marriages over it.
9 Q. What was that last part?
10 A. I said I broke up both my own marriages over
11 it.
12 Q. Did you ever talk to [Johnny Doe 3]’s parents
13 about any of this?
14 A. I don’t think so.
15 MR. WALKER: Any of what, Counsel?
16 MR. DOLAN: Q. Any of these issues regarding
17 pedophilia.
18 A. No. I never met his father, and I knew his
19 mother only as part of SCA.
20 Q. The Society for Creative Anachronism?
21 A. That’s right.
22 Q. Do you know what the syntax dictionary?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Do you know who had it last?
25 A. I haven’t any idea.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
47
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Did you ever see a letter from Dr. Morin
2 about [Johnny Doe 3]?
3 A. Who’s Dr. Morin?
4 Q. Dr. Morin was one of Walter’s psychologists.
5 A. I can’t remember any such letter. I don’t
6 believe I ever knew him. As far as I know, I never met
7 the man.
8 Q. Who’s [Johnny Doe 4]?
9 A. The name doesn’t ring a bell.
10 Q. I’m going to read to you from the 10-9-89
11 entry of Elisabeth Waters.
12 “Marion always said she’d divorce Walter if
13 he did this again. She seems to think that he molested
14 both [Victim X] and [Johnny Doe 4], but she was rather startled
when I
15 told her about the letter to Dr. Morin about [Johnny Doe
3].
16 She said that she thought Walter thought of [Johnny Doe
3] as
17 a son.”
18 Let me ask you a few questions about that
19 statement. Does that refresh your recollection about a
20 letter from Dr. Morin?
21 A. Yes, it does.
22 Q. Can you now tell me what you recall?
23 A. Yes. I can remember discussing the fact that
24 he thought of him as a son because Moira and Patrick
25 both thought of [Johnny Doe 3] as a brother.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
48
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Did you talk to Walter about any sexual
2 activity between himself and [Johnny Doe 3]?
3 A. It never occurred to me.
4 Q. It didn’t occur to you to talk about it?
5 A. No. I wouldn’t even have thought about it.
6 Q. Do you recall the letter from Dr. Morin now?
7 A. I never saw any such letters.
8 Q. Did Elisabeth ever tell you about a letter to
9 Dr. Morin about [Johnny Doe 3] that Walter had written?
10 A. No.
11 Q. Did you ever tell Elisabeth that you thought
12 Walter had molested both [Victim X] and [Johnny Doe 4]?
13 A. I can’t remember. I don’t believe I ever
14 discussed it with Elisabeth, but I might have in
15 passing.
16 Q. If Elisabeth states that you discussed it
17 with her, do you deny having those discussions?
18 A. No, I wouldn’t deny it. But I think she
19 might have written in her diary and forgotten to read it
20 to me or something. Elisabeth does not have the
21 greatest memory in the world either.
22 Q. I’ve noticed.
23 Do you have any recollection of anybody named
24 [Johnny Doe 4] ever being over at the house?
25 A. I think Moira had a boyfriend of that name.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
49
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Do you have any understanding as to whether
2 [Johnny Doe 4] was ever molested by Walter Breen?
3 A. I wouldn’t have inquired into the matter or
4 thought about it.
5 Q. Did you know that Walter had a lot of young
6 boys over at the house?
7 A. No. I didn’t notice. I was never over at
8 the goldfish bowl.
9 Q. How about when he was living with you?
10 A. Well, he had friends, yes.
11 Q. Young boys?
12 A. Occasionally.
13 Q. Did Walter have an unusual number of young
14 boyfriends for a man of his age?
15 A. I wouldn’t think so.
16 Q. Did you state that you would divorce Walter
17 if he ever did this again?
18 A. Yes, I did.
19 Q. What did you mean by doing this again?
20 A. I meant if he ever molested a young boy
21 again.
22 Q. And when you say “again,” who were the other
23 young boys that you were talking about him molesting?
24 A. [Victim X] especially.
25 Q. Any others?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
50
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 A. I can’t remember any offhand.
2 Q. Are you aware of there being others?
3 A. There might have been. I would not have
4 inquired into the matter.
5 Q. But to your knowledge, there might have been
6 others besides [Victim X]?
7 A. There might have been.
8 Q. But you didn’t specifically inquire into
9 that?
10 A. At the time I did not. I can look back now
11 and see there might have been, but I didn’t know at the
12 time.
13 Q. Did you ever warn any people in the general
14 public about Walter’s tastes for young boys?
15 A. No.
16 Q. Did you know that Walter was attending
17 conventions where lots of young children were?
18 A. I think he had only been to coin conventions,
19 and they sort of flocked around him like — like bees
20 around honey. He was an expert on coins and an
21 authority on the subject.
22 Q. Okay. Did Walter ever attend science fiction
23 conventions?
24 A. Once or twice.
25 Q. Did you pay for his attendance at those
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
51
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 conventions?
2 A. Yes, I did.
3 Q. As somebody who was paying for his attendance
4 at those conventions, did you ever warn people at the
5 convention that Walter was a pedophile?
6 THE WITNESS: No.
7 MR. BAKER: Objection. Argumentative.
8 MR. WALKER: I’ll join that.
9 THE WITNESS: I did not.
10 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever warn any of the
11 people at the convention about Walter’s tastes in young
12 boys?
13 THE WITNESS: No.
14 MR. BAKER: Objection. Lacks foundation.
15 THE WITNESS: Never occurred to me.
16 MR. DOLAN: Q. You were aware that Walter
17 had a sexual appetite for young boys?
18 A. I suppose I was.
19 Q. Did you ever warn people at the conventions
20 of Walter’s sexual appetite for young boys?
21 THE WITNESS: No, I did not.
22 MR. BAKER: Same objections.
23 MR. DOLAN: Q. Indeed you defended Walter’s
24 expulsion from a convention on the basis of pedophilia,
25 didn’t you?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
52
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 MR. BAKER: Objection. Argumentative.
2 THE WITNESS: Yes, I did.
3 MR. DOLAN: Q. So in addition to never
4 warning people, you actually defended his presence
5 there, didn’t you?
6 MR. BAKER: Objection. Argumentative.
7 MR. WALKER: Asked and answered.
8 MR. DOLAN: Q. You can answer.
9 A. I thought it was his own business.
10 Q. Okay.
11 A. And we did not discuss the subject, as far as
12 I can remember.
13 Q. Did he attend these coin conferences as an
14 employee of yours?
15 A. No, he did not. I had no interest in the
16 coin business.
17 Q. I’m talking about the science fiction
18 conventions.
19 A. No, he did not.
20 Q. Why did you pay his way, then?
21 A. Because he was my husband. He had shared
22 things with me when we were very poor; and then when I
23 got money, I shared things with him.
24 Q. Maybe we could take a break. Are you okay?
25 A. Yes, I’m fine.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
53
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 Q. Was Walter an employee of yours during the
2 time that he attended these conventions?
3 A. No.
4 Q. Was he ever an employee of yours?
5 A. I believe he wrote some articles for the
6 magazine.
7 Q. Did you ever pay him as an employee?
8 A. No. I paid him for what he wrote and was
9 printed in the magazine.
10 Q. Was he ever paid a salary by you or your
11 company?
12 A. I don’t think so. I don’t remember very
13 clearly. I seldom think much about money at all.
14 Q. Okay.
15 A. The thing is that when we were very broke, he
16 was always very good about sharing his poverty with me;
17 and then when I began to make money, I shared everything
18 I had with him.
19 MR. DOLAN: I’m looking for some guidance
20 here. We okay here?
21 MR. WALKER: I mean, we only have about five
22 more minutes left. Are you okay to keep —
23 THE WITNESS: Yeah, I’m fine.
24 MR. DOLAN: I’m going to take a break for two
25 minutes, and I’ll take my five minutes, and we’ll be out
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
54
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 of here. Okay?
2 MR. WALKER: Okay.
3 MR. DOLAN: I just need to talk to Scott for
4 a moment.
5 (Mr. Dolan and Mr. Bonagofsky exit and
6 return.)
7 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever tell Elisabeth
8 Waters that children didn’t have erogenous zones?
9 A. I may well have.
10 Q. Do you have the belief that children don’t
11 have erogenous zones?
12 A. At the time I believed it.
13 Q. And what time was that?
14 A. I think it was probably when my own kids were
15 young.
16 Q. Are you aware of Walter writing any posthumus
17 letters to Ken Smith?
18 A. Posthumus letters?
19 Q. There is some indication that he had written
20 letters to be delivered posthumously.
21 A. I thought if he wanted it —
22 Q. Did you ever receive such a letter?
23 A. No.
24 — he would have written it to me.
25 Q. Did you ever state to your daughter that
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
55
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 these young boys got what they deserved?
2 A. I don’t remember.
3 Q. You don’t remember either way?
4 A. No.
5 Q. All right. Did you attend the Westercon 4 on
6 Halloween weekend in 1982?
7 A. I believe so.
8 Q. Did you attend the Westercon 5 in 1985 on
9 Halloween weekend?
10 A. I don’t remember.
11 Q. Do you have records of what conferences you
12 attended?
13 A. No.
14 Q. Did you attend the 1984 Nebula Awards?
15 A. I probably did. I attend — you’d have to
16 tell me when it was held. I go to them if they’re
17 anywhere within my traveling capacity.
18 Q. Okay. In New York, the 1984 Nebula Awards.
19 A. No.
20 Q. Were you aware that Ken Smith was spending
21 time with Walter Breen over at the other home that you
22 rented to Walter Breen?
23 A. I never saw Ken Smith and, to the best of my
24 knowledge, I never heard of him.
25 Q. Did you speak to the police following the
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
56
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 arrest for the molestation of Ken Smith?
2 A. I don’t remember, but I don’t think so. I
3 probably would have remembered it.
4 Q. There are statements attributed to you in the
5 police report following the molestation of Ken Smith.
6 A. I don’t remember them.
7 Q. If you had spoken to the police, would you
8 have been truthful and correct to them?
9 A. Yes, I would.
10 Q. The police officer records, quote, “I
11 asked” — and this is on page — it’s not listed by
12 page, but it’s Report No. 89-42141, which has been
13 provided previously to counsel. And it’s a date of —
14 MR. WALKER: Do you have a copy of that right
15 now?
16 MR. DOLAN: — 2-6-90.
17 Let’s mark this as the next in order. It’s
18 going to be the fourth page back.
19 (Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 3 was marked for
20 identification.)
21 MR. DOLAN: Q. I’m going to show you what’s
22 been marked as Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 3, and I’m going
23 to refer you to Page 4, the last paragraph of
24 Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 3, Page 4. Quote, “I asked if
25 she knew Ken Smith, and she said met him in the fall of
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
57
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 1988, briefly because Breen had brought him over, but
2 that she does not know his family.”
3 Does that refresh your recollection as to
4 whether or not you had met Ken Smith?
5 A. I don’t remember him.
6 Q. Okay. So you don’t remember either way?
7 A. No, I don’t. I’ve been racking my brains
8 back and forth, but I can’t remember ever meeting Ken
9 Smith.
10 Q. In 1990, in that same page, you told the
11 officer you did not think that Breen was actually
12 engaging in sexual activity with young boys.
13 A. I believed that at the time.
14 Q. At that time you knew that he had sexual
15 activity with [Victim X] when [Victim X] was under the age
16 of 18, didn’t you?
17 A. Yes, I did. But as I said, [Victim X] was
18 a teenager, and, as I remember, this was some little kid
19 around 10, 12 years old.
20 Q. Would 12 years old be too young, in your
21 opinion, then?
22 MR. BAKER: Calls for speculation.
23 MR. WALKER: Join.
24 THE WITNESS: No opinion.
25 MR. WALKER: Counsel, I think we’re just
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
58
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 about done with the hour and —
2 MR. DOLAN: Sure. We’ll set up a another
3 date.
4 Thank you for your time. We were going to
5 suspend but not conclude your deposition today. Okay?
6 THE WITNESS: Yes, sir.
7 MR. DOLAN: Have a good day, ma’am.
8 THE WITNESS: You too.
9 (Whereupon, the deposition adjourned at 12:01
10 p.m.)
11
12
13
14 MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
59
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY – 8/10/98
1 I, the undersigned, hereby certify that the
2 witness in the foregoing deposition was, by me, duly
3 sworn to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but
4 the truth in the within-entitled cause.
5
6 That said deposition was taken in shorthand by
7 me, a Certified Shorthand Reporter and a disinterested
8 person, at the time and place therein stated, and that
9 the testimony of said witness was thereafter reduced to
10 typewriting, by computer, under my direction and
11 supervision.
12
13 I further certify that I am not of counsel or
14 attorney for either or any of the parties of the said
15 deposition, nor in any way interested in the event of
16 this cause, and that I am not related to any of the
17 parties thereto.
18
19 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my
20 hand, this 25th day of August 1998.
21
22
23
24 ________________________
Janine P. Branco
25 CSR #10372
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
60
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
2 FOR THE COUNTY OF ALAMEDA
3 —o0o—
4 KEN SMITH, )
)
5 Plaintiff, )
)
6 vs. ) No. 778220-2
)
7 MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, ELISabeth )
WATERS, and DOES 1 through 10, )
8 )
Defendants. )
9 __________________________________)
10
11
12
13
14 DEPOSITION OF
15 MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY
16 VOLUME II – PAGES 61 THROUGH 120
17 _________________________________
18 Monday, December 14, 1998
19
20
21 SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES
1254 Leavenworth Street
22 San Francisco, California 94109
(415) 771-1988
23
24
25 REPORTED BY: JANINE P. BRANCO, CSR No. 10372
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
61
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1
2 I N D E X
3 EXAMINATION BY: PAGE
4 MR. DOLAN (Resumed) 64
5 —o0o—
6 E X H I B I T S
7 PLAINTIFF’S PAGE
8 4 2-page 6-6-54 typewritten document. 99
9 5 1-page 2-1-86 document entitled 115
“Rental Agreement.”
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
62
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 BE IT REMEMBERED THAT, pursuant to Notice of
2 Taking Deposition and on Monday, December 14, 1998,
3 commencing at the hour of 11:24 a.m. thereof, at 200
4 Marina Boulevard, Room 1102, Berkeley, California, before
5 me, JANINE P. BRANCO, a Certified Shorthand Reporter of
6 the State of California, personally appeared
7 MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY
8 a Defendant herein, called as a witness by the Plaintiff,
9 having been by me first duly sworn, was examined and
10 testified further hereinafter as set forth.
11 —o0o—
12 APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL
13 For the Plaintiff Ken Smith
THE LAW OFFICES OF CHRISTOPHER B. DOLAN
14 655 Montgomery Street, 16th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94111
15 By: CHRISTOPHER B. DOLAN, Attorney at Law
16 For the Defendant Marion Zimmer Bradley
CAUDLE, WELCH, UMIPEG & BOVEE
17 1390 Willow Pass Road, Suite 200
Concord, CA 94520
18 By: M. HENRY WALKER, Attorney at Law
19 For the Defendant Elisabeth Waters
HAIMS, JOHNSON, MacGOWAN & McINERNEY
20 490 Grand Avenue
Oakland, CA 94610
21 By: LAWRENCE A. BAKER, Attorney at Law
22 ALSO PRESENT:
23 BELLE ROMERO
24 —o0o—
25
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
63
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 EXAMINATION BY MR. DOLAN (Resumed)
2 Q. Ms. Zimmer Bradley, we’re going forward with
3 your deposition today based upon the limitations that have
4 been imposed by your doctors and your counsel; so we will
5 have no more than one hour today of deposition.
6 Do you understand that?
7 A. Yes, I do. Thank you.
8 Q. I’ve also agreed with your counsel not to delve
9 into particular areas during this session of your
10 deposition.
11 Do you understand that?
12 A. Well, I think I know what you mean.
13 Q. Okay. I will not be asking any questions about
14 your relationship with your daughter.
15 Do you understand that?
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. I reserve my right to do so at a future date;
18 okay?
19 A. Okay.
20 Q. Who is the president today?
21 A. William Clinton.
22 Q. Do you know who the vice president is?
23 A. I am not sure.
24 Q. Do you know who the governor of the State of
25 California is?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
64
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. The last I heard it was Willie Brown.
2 Q. Okay. And do you know who was elected governor
3 recently?
4 A. Gray Davis.
5 Q. Do you know what party Gray Davis is a member
6 of?
7 A. I think he’s a democrat.
8 Q. Do you know what day today is?
9 A. December 12th or 13th, 1998.
10 Q. Do you know what day of the week it is?
11 A. Monday.
12 Q. How many children do you have?
13 A. Three.
14 Q. Where is your home when you’re not living in
15 this hotel?
16 A. 2223 — 2223 Fulton Street, Berkeley,
17 California.
18 Q. Okay.
19 A. It’s just — it’s just —
20 It’s between Shattuck and Telegraph almost
21 exactly.
22 Q. Do you have another home that you own besides
23 that one?
24 A. Yes, I do. We just purchased a place on Fulton
25 Street.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
65
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. Okay. Where do you live when you’re not living
2 here?
3 A. I live at Fulton Street, not — yes, I live at
4 the Fulton Street house.
5 Q. Do you ever live on Prince Street when you’re
6 not living here?
7 A. Well, it’s on the corner of Prince and Fulton.
8 They run into each other.
9 Q. What are your children’s names?
10 A. My oldest son is named David Steven Bradley; my
11 second son is Patrick Russell Breen; and my daughter is
12 named Moira Stern. She’s married to Robert Stern.
13 Q. Do you have a nurse here today?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. What is your nurse’s name?
16 A. Belle.
17 Q. Do you know where Moira lives?
18 A. At the moment I think she’s living somewhere in
19 Novato. She’s going to the university there to work on a
20 master’s degree.
21 Q. The reason I was asking you those questions is
22 to try to determine whether or not you’re —
23 A. Whether I’m oriented in time and space.
24 Q. Right.
25 Are you feeling sufficiently oriented in time
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
66
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 and space to go forward with your deposition today?
2 A. Yes; I think so.
3 Q. Have you seen any physicians in the past week
4 that have indicated that you’re unable to go forward with
5 this deposition?
6 A. No.
7 I’ve seen three physicians. None of them have
8 mentioned the deposition.
9 Q. And do you have any knowledge of why we cannot
10 go forward with your deposition today?
11 A. No.
12 Q. Very good.
13 I’m going to go over the rules of a deposition
14 with you again, even though we’ve gone over them once
15 before —
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. — just to make sure we’re both familiar with
18 the rules of a deposition; okay?
19 A. Okay.
20 Q. The first rule of a deposition is I do not want
21 you to guess or speculate as to anything that’s said here
22 today.
23 Do you understand that?
24 A. Yes, I do.
25 Q. I understand that you’ve had some strokes and
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
67
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 that you may have some memory problems, but I don’t want
2 you to guess or make anything up merely to be helpful
3 today.
4 A. If I don’t remember something, I just say I
5 don’t remember it.
6 Q. That will be fine. Thank you.
7 The second thing is we need to talk in turn,
8 only one person talking at a time because the court
9 reporter can only take down written statements of one
10 person at a time.
11 So if you’ll wait until I finish my questions
12 before you begin your answers, or wait for the attorneys
13 to finish their objections before you begin your answers,
14 that will be very helpful to us today.
15 Will you do that?
16 A. Yes; I’ll try to do so. I can’t guarantee it.
17 I tend to — people ask me things, and I tend to speak
18 without thinking.
19 Q. Okay. That’s fine.
20 Everything that’s done here today needs to be
21 said in a full English language spoken word. We have to
22 use English, and we have to avoid grunts and groans, but
23 use “yes,” “no” or any other combination of words that you
24 feel suitable or appropriate.
25 Do you understand that?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
68
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. I’ll do my best.
2 Q. If you do not understand my question, ask me to
3 help you understand the question. Tell me you don’t
4 understand the question or somehow otherwise let us know
5 because if we receive an answer to a question, I will
6 assume that you understood the question asked of you.
7 Is that clear?
8 A. Yes, it is.
9 Q. At the end of the deposition process, you’ll
10 have an opportunity to review the booklet that’s being
11 typed by the woman to my right, to your left. You’ll have
12 an opportunity to make any changes in the transcript you’d
13 like, that reads a lot like a script or a novel like you
14 may have written in the past, and you can edit it and make
15 changes to it.
16 I must caution you, however, that if you edit
17 it or make changes to it of a substantive nature, I can
18 comment on that at trial, or any other lawyer can comment
19 on that at trial in order to make you look bad or to show
20 that you may not be truthful or to say your memory is not
21 very good.
22 So if you think of something you need to change
23 today, please try to do that today so that we can avoid
24 the embarrassment later on.
25 Is that clear?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
69
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. Yes, it is.
2 Q. Have you read your last session of your
3 deposition?
4 A. Well, yes. But since it was — all the
5 questions were on one page and the answers on another, I
6 found it very confusing.
7 Q. Okay. Is that your deposition or your
8 Interrogatory answers; do you know?
9 A. I don’t know the meaning of those words.
10 Q. Okay. A deposition is the booklet that’s being
11 written up by the court reporter to our right. It’s a
12 question-and-answer thing. It reads a lot like a script.
13 And this is a copy of your deposition from the first
14 session, which has questions and answers (indicating).
15 Did you read something like that?
16 A. No. The one that I saw had the questions on
17 one page and the answers on another one and nothing but
18 numbers on them to keep them straight with.
19 Q. Something more like this that I’m showing you,
20 your responses to requests for —
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. — admissions?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. Okay. Is there any reason that you’re aware of
25 why your deposition should not go forward today?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
70
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. None that I’m aware of.
2 Q. Are you living in this hotel currently?
3 A. Yes, I am.
4 Q. And for how long have you been residing in this
5 hotel?
6 A. Two weeks.
7 Q. Do you have any understanding of how long you
8 expect to reside in this hotel?
9 A. Hopefully we’ll be out of here in another week.
10 They have a — they have a place for me for — a temporary
11 one at a disabled apartment.
12 Q. Very good.
13 Have you been traveling out of the hotel
14 anywhere to go to conventions or to any types of events?
15 A. No, I have not.
16 I have been taken out to lunch once or twice.
17 That is about all.
18 Q. Okay. When did you first start living with
19 Walter Breen?
20 A. In, I think it was, 1963.
21 Q. And how did you come to know him prior to 1963?
22 A. We had been corresponding. We were both
23 members of what at that time was known as Science Fiction
24 Phantom. We both were readers of science fiction, and we
25 would write to each other and discuss the stories and the
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
71
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 writers, and occasionally other items of interest.
2 Naturally we found we had interests in common and began
3 speaking to each other frequently on the telephone.
4 Q. Had you met personally prior to corresponding
5 with him?
6 A. Not at first. I met with him about the middle
7 of the time.
8 Q. Where did you first meet him?
9 A. New York City.
10 Q. Did you understand him to be living there at
11 the time?
12 A. Yes, I did.
13 Q. Were you living in New York City at the time?
14 A. No, I was not. I was living in Albany with my
15 mother and father.
16 Q. Have you retained any of the correspondence
17 that you initially had with Walter?
18 A. No.
19 Q. Okay. When did your relationship develop in
20 terms of years to the time that you two began to live in
21 the same city?
22 A. I —
23 I am a little doubtful, but what happened was
24 that we had been talking to each other frequently on the
25 telephone, and then I decided to leave my home and move to
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
72
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 the University, to Berkeley, University of California to
2 do graduate work there, and he said that I could stay with
3 him, and I accepted the invitation. And when I went out
4 there we moved in together.
5 Q. When you say you moved out there, is that
6 New York or California?
7 A. California.
8 Q. So the first time that you lived with Walter
9 was in California?
10 A. Yes. We had met several times before that but
11 briefly.
12 Q. When you came to California, did you live with
13 anyone other than Walter?
14 A. Yes. For a time I lived with Miriam Knight.
15 Q. And that is whom in relationship to you?
16 A. Well, she’s just another lady that I met
17 through Phantom. She was married to a friend of mine.
18 Q. She still alive?
19 A. I don’t have the slightest idea. I haven’t
20 seen her in years. When Walter died we went to Las Vegas
21 to wait out a divorce. Marium agreed to keep my son and
22 took care of David during the six weeks I was in Novato.
23 Q. And her last name was Night, N-i-g-h-t?
24 A. K-n-i-g-h-t.
25 Q. And do you know where she lived the last time
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
73
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 that you knew of her to be in existence?
2 A. The last time I knew of her she had — I think
3 she had a child. I remember that she and I and Grania
4 Davis were all expecting children at the same time. I’m
5 trying to remember. I think she was living in an
6 apartment in Berkeley.
7 Q. Do you know if she ever changed her name from
8 Knight to something else?
9 A. I don’t remember.
10 Q. So you began living with Walter sometime in
11 1964 — is that right? — in Berkeley or —
12 A. I think it was very early in ’64.
13 Q. When did you marry him?
14 A. ’64. Later in the year, about June.
15 Q. Prior to marrying Walter did you ever discuss
16 his relationship with any young men under the age of 18?
17 A. I think the subject may have come up in
18 passing, fleetingly. Certainly very little impression on
19 me.
20 Q. When you say the subject “may have come up in
21 passing, fleetingly,” can you tell me what you can recall
22 about the subject coming up prior to your marrying him?
23 A. Maybe at that point we were discussing
24 civilization and the fact that young men among the
25 Greeks — well, the women, of course, at that time were
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
74
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 idiots and uneducated and living in Perdock, and so the
2 men had emotional and friendly relationships with members
3 of their own sex, and that formed the topic of
4 conversation. It was an interesting subject. We talked
5 about it a bit.
6 Q. And at that point did Walter confide to you
7 that he had sexual relationships with young men?
8 A. He did.
9 Q. And do you have an understanding of the names
10 of any of those young men?
11 A. No.
12 Q. Did he give you an indication of how many
13 occasions he had sexual relationships with different young
14 men?
15 A. No. We did not talk much about it. I gather
16 it was something that just came up now and then.
17 Q. So it was your understanding it was something
18 that Walter would engage in now and then?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. You understand that these sexual relationships
21 were with young men under the age of 18?
22 A. I didn’t know.
23 Q. Did you form any understanding as to the
24 approximate age of the young men with which Walter was
25 having sexual relationships?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
75
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. No, I did not. He was in his 30s, so I
2 naturally assumed they would be in their 20s or 30s also.
3 Q. Didn’t you come to know about [Victim X]l
4 prior to marrying Walter?
5 A. Yes, I did.
6 Q. You knew he was under the age of 18, didn’t
7 you?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. So when you said naturally they were in their
10 20s to 30s, you knew of at least one that they weren’t 20
11 to 30?
12 A. Yes; I knew of that one exception.
13 Q. Did you inquire as to any other exceptions?
14 A. No, I did not.
15 Q. Did you prior to marrying Walter Breen inform
16 him that he was to have no sexual contact with your minor
17 children?
18 A. It never occurred to me one way or the other.
19 Q. To your knowledge, did Walter ever have sexual
20 contact with your son David?
21 A. I asked David one time about it, and he told me
22 one of Walter’s friends had propositioned him and that he
23 said no, and so the friend said, “Okay. Let’s go ride the
24 merry-go-round.”
25 Q. Okay. Tell me when you and David had this
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
76
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 conversation.
2 A. I think it was sometime in ’64. Might have
3 been early ’65.
4 Q. And how old was David at that time?
5 A. I think he was 13 or 14.
6 Q. Do you know the name of the person who
7 propositioned him?
8 A. Yes, I do. His name was Robert Bashlow.
9 Q. Could you spell —
10 A. B-a-s-h-l-o-w.
11 Q. What occasioned you to ask your son David about
12 whether or not he had been propositioned by anyone?
13 A. Because I knew Robert Bashlow, and I knew that
14 anything with two legs which got in his vicinity was
15 likely to be propositioned.
16 Q. I didn’t hear the last part.
17 A. I said that anyone in his vicinity of either
18 gender was likely to be propositioned. I never paid much
19 attention because my attitude was well no harm in asking
20 as long he takes no for an answer.
21 Q. So your —
22 So your understanding at that time in 1964 is
23 that there was nothing inappropriate about an older man
24 asking a minor for sex so long as the young boy said no?
25 A. As long as the young boy is given plenty of
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
77
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 opportunity to say no.
2 Q. At that time did you also believe if the young
3 boy had said yes that would be okay then?
4 A. I had not thought a great deal about the
5 matter, but I suppose yes, that is a fair statement.
6 Q. Okay. Did you ever ask your son whether Walter
7 propositioned your son? We’ve mentioned now about this
8 other gentleman, Mr. Bashlow, but did you ever ask your
9 son whether Walter ever propositioned David?
10 A. It came up a few years ago.
11 Q. Tell me how it came up.
12 A. Well, somebody was talking about it, and
13 afterwards I said to David, “Did Walter ever say anything
14 to you about it?” and he said, “No. I was too old. I
15 didn’t pay much attention to it.”
16 He wrote me a letter saying that Walter had
17 been a very good stepfather to him. I think his exact
18 words were that when it came to stepfathers he got the
19 pick of the bisque.
20 Q. He had the what, the pick of the basket?
21 A. Pick of the bisque.
22 Q. Where did you have this discussion with David
23 where he thought he was too old for Walter?
24 A. When he was 15 or so.
25 Q. About 15?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
78
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. That’s when you discussed this with him?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. So at the time that David was 15, David
5 informed you that he believed that your then husband was
6 not propositioning him because at that point David was too
7 old for Walter’s tastes?
8 A. I think that’s what he said. To the best of my
9 memory, that’s what he said.
10 Q. Was that consistent with your understanding at
11 that time that David at the age of 15 would be too old for
12 Walter’s tastes in partners?
13 MR. BAKER: Objection. Lacks foundation.
14 MR. DOLAN: Q. You can answer.
15 MR. WALKER: I’ll join in that.
16 MR. DOLAN: Q. You can answer.
17 MR. WALKER: Go ahead and answer it, if you
18 can.
19 THE WITNESS: I don’t know.
20 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever undertake any
21 inquiry after David said that to find out exactly what
22 Walter’s tastes were in terms of young men?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Did it trouble you at all that your son — that
25 your husband was interested in boys under his age?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
79
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. No, it didn’t. At that time my husband and I
2 were very in love, and I had no reason to suspect that his
3 interests lay anywhere else.
4 Q. But you had asked your son that question?
5 A. It came up in conversation.
6 Q. How did it come up in conversation?
7 A. I haven’t the least idea.
8 Q. To the best of your recollection, how did this
9 come up in conversation?
10 A. I’m sorry. I can’t remember. It was just
11 something we were talking about.
12 Q. So, was a topic of conversation in your family
13 Walter’s interests in young boys —
14 A. It could have been.
15 Q. — back when your son was as young as 15?
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. When was your son born?
18 A. 1950, I think.
19 Q. And it was a topic of conversation such that
20 you asked your son whether Walter had ever propositioned
21 him; correct?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. And so you were concerned enough to ask your
24 own son whether your husband had propositioned him
25 sexually?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
80
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. I wouldn’t say I was concerned. I meant the
2 subject had come up and I was curious.
3 Q. So you were curious enough to ask your own son
4 whether your husband had made a sexual proposition to him?
5 A. I wouldn’t say I was concerned enough. I would
6 simply say the matter came up in conversation.
7 Q. Okay. When your son indicated that he had been
8 propositioned by Robert Bashlow, did you do anything to
9 prohibit Mr. Bashlow from coming in contact with your son?
10 A. No. I think I might have thought it was funny.
11 Q. So you thought the fact that an older man
12 propositioned your then 13-year-old son was funny?
13 A. I thought Robert Bashlow was a pretty funny
14 individual.
15 Q. And you took no steps to prevent your son from
16 coming in contact with a man who you knew had
17 propositioned him?
18 A. Considering that David was almost six feet and
19 Bashlow, as I remember, was about five foot, one, I didn’t
20 worry about it.
21 Q. You’re saying your son was six feet tall at the
22 age of 13?
23 A. Pretty near.
24 Q. So the question again is —
25 A. He’s now six foot, six.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
81
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. The question is: Did you undertake any action
2 to prevent any further contact between Robert Bashlow and
3 your then 13-year-old son after you learned that
4 Mr. Bashlow had sexually propositioned your son?
5 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
6 MR. WALKER: I’ll join in that objection.
7 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer it.
8 MR. WALKER: You can go ahead.
9 THE WITNESS: Well, I would say that — that
10 that was much more David’s business than anyone else.
11 MR. DOLAN: Q. So you didn’t do anything to
12 prevent Mr. Bashlow, did you, from coming in contact with
13 your son?
14 A. No, I did not.
15 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
16 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you discuss it with your —
17 please take your water.
18 MR. WALKER: I’m going to join in that last
19 objection.
20 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you discuss this
21 proposition of your then 13-year-old son by one of
22 Walter’s friends with Walter?
23 A. The subject may have come up in conversation.
24 Q. Okay. To the best of your recollection, tell
25 me how that subject may have come up in conversation.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
82
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. Well, I think one of us would have said to the
2 other, Do you know what that idiot Bashlow has done now?
3 Q. Okay. I don’t want you to guess or speculate.
4 Do you recall what Walter said in any regard regarding the
5 issue of Robert Bashlow propositioning your 13-year-old
6 son for sex?
7 MR. BAKER: Objection. Speculation.
8 MR. DOLAN: Q. You can answer.
9 MR. WALKER: I’ll join in that.
10 You can answer.
11 THE WITNESS: All I know is that Bash — that
12 Bashlow’s regarded largely as a laughing stock by most of
13 our friends.
14 MR. DOLAN: Q. Right. Okay. My question is a
15 little bit more specific, though. Do you recall Walter
16 saying anything to you on the subject of Bashlow
17 propositioning your 13-year-old son?
18 A. As I said, I think he said something like, Do
19 you know what that idiot Bashlow has done now? and then he
20 recounted a story.
21 Q. Did he express any —
22 To your knowledge, did he express anything that
23 you understood to be disapproval to what Mr. Bashlow had
24 done?
25 A. I think at the time he shared my belief that
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
83
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 David was perfectly old enough to make his own decisions
2 of that sort.
3 Q. Okay. So at that time it was your belief that
4 a 13-year-old child was perfectly able to make their own
5 decisions regarding sexual contact with adults?
6 A. Oh, really, a-13-year-old child? I wasn’t a
7 child at 13, were you?
8 Q. The question —
9 Could you read back the question for her,
10 please?
11 (Record read by reporter.)
12 MR. DOLAN: Q. Do you have the question in
13 mind?
14 A. I never thought that I was very intelligent,
15 but this — my opinion at the moment was that 13-year-old
16 young people were quite old enough to decide what they
17 wanted to do.
18 Q. Okay. Did you have any understanding at that
19 time as to whether the law was in contrast with your
20 opinion on the issue of 13-year-old children making
21 decisions about sex with adults?
22 A. I don’t think I ever inquired into the matter.
23 Q. I’m going to show you some pictures, and I’m
24 going to ask you if you can identify anybody in these
25 pictures.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
84
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. No.
2 Let me see here. No. At first I thought this
3 was a picture of David in his teens, but it’s not.
4 Q. To your knowledge, have you seen a picture of
5 that boy before in the pictures? Have you ever seen that
6 boy?
7 A. Not to my memory, no.
8 Q. Looking at the pictures of the young boy in
9 those pictures, do you think that boy is of the age to
10 make decisions whether or not he should be having sex with
11 adults?
12 MR. BAKER: Objection. Speculation.
13 MR. WALKER: I’ll join in that. And also lacks
14 foundation. She’s never seen those pictures before.
15 MR. DOLAN: Q. Okay. I’m just asking you,
16 does it appear the ages of those young boys in those
17 pictures are of the age to be making decisions as to
18 whether they should be having sex with adults?
19 MR. BAKER: Objection. Lacks foundation. She
20 doesn’t know the boy. She’s never even seen the picture.
21 MR. WALKER: Just a second. We don’t even know
22 what age that is.
23 MR. BAKER: It’s also vague. Speculation.
24 THE WITNESS: What I was going to say is that
25 I’m not a psychological counselor or a school teacher.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
85
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 MR. DOLAN: Q. Right. You indicated, though,
2 that you think children at a particular age are able to
3 make decisions whether or not they’re going to have sex
4 with adults. That was your personal belief; right?
5 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
6 MR. WALKER: I’ll join.
7 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer.
8 MR. WALKER: Go ahead.
9 THE WITNESS: I would say that my personal
10 opinions are not at issue in this matter.
11 MR. DOLAN: Q. Okay. I would disagree with
12 you, and I would ask you to answer my question.
13 A. I would say that you are entitled to your
14 opinion, sir.
15 Q. I’m asking your opinion.
16 A. My opinion is my opinion.
17 MR. BAKER: She’s already answered it.
18 MR. DOLAN: She’s refusing to answer the
19 question.
20 MR. BAKER: She’s already —
21 MR. WALKER: She has already answered that.
22 MR. DOLAN: Q. Are you of the understanding
23 that children at some particular age are capable of making
24 decisions about whether or not to have sex with adults?
25 A. I never claimed to be of great psychological
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
86
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 knowledge, but on the surface of it I thought so at the
2 time.
3 Q. Right.
4 A. What I think now has no relevance.
5 Q. Okay. Well, at what time did you think it was
6 appropriate for children to begin to make the decision
7 whether or not to have sex with adults?
8 A. I don’t believe I speculated.
9 MR. WALKER: At what time are you talking?
10 MR. DOLAN: She said “at the time.”
11 MR. WALKER: Okay. But you’re asking the
12 question. You have to make your question better. I’m
13 sorry.
14 MR. DOLAN: Q. At the point you indicated at
15 the time you had an understanding of when children could
16 begin to make decisions regarding sex with adults, what
17 time are you referring to, what time period?
18 A. I would say that in their middle teens most
19 teenagers are perfectly capable of deciding what they
20 want.
21 Q. Okay. When did you come to form that opinion
22 in time? Was it in the ’60s? The ’70s?
23 A. During my own teens, in the ’40s and ’50s.
24 Q. All right. And did you retain that opinion in
25 the ’60s?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
87
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. I don’t know when I began to change my
2 opinions.
3 Q. Do you have any knowledge if you began to
4 change your opinions prior to marrying Walter Breen?
5 A. I don’t know.
6 Q. Well, at the time that your son had informed
7 you that he had been approached by Mr. Bashlow, you still
8 were of the opinion that he at the age of 13 could make
9 that decision; right?
10 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
11 MR. WALKER: Join in that.
12 You can go ahead.
13 THE WITNESS: I would say that — as I say,
14 Robert Bashlow was enough of a laughing stock that I never
15 took anything he did seriously as a danger to anyone,
16 including a kitten.
17 MR. DOLAN: Q. The question I asked you,
18 though, is different, which was: At the time that that
19 incident happened between Robert Bashlow and your son, did
20 you believe that a 13 year old could make decisions as to
21 whether or not it was appropriate to have sex with an
22 adult?
23 MR. BAKER: Objection.
24 MR. WALKER: Same objections.
25 MR. BAKER: Asked and answered about ten times
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
88
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 now.
2 THE WITNESS: I certainly think that David knew
3 what he was doing at that time and if Bashlow said
4 anything to him that he didn’t like he could have broken
5 Bashlow in two with one hand, so I never took it very
6 seriously as a danger.
7 MR. DOLAN: Q. Okay. If the 13 year old
8 wasn’t six feet tall, did you have any opinion that child,
9 let’s say a four-foot-tall 13 year old, it would be
10 appropriate to proposition them for sex?
11 MR. BAKER: Objection. Vague. Lacks
12 foundation. Compound.
13 MR. WALKER: I’ll join those objections.
14 MR. DOLAN: Q. You can answer. You may answer
15 it.
16 A. I did not speculate on the matter. If it came
17 up, it came up very briefly and crossed my mind very
18 quickly.
19 Q. How tall was [Victim X]?
20 A. I don’t remember.
21 Q. Did you ever meet him?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. Can you recall about how tall he was at the
24 time that Walter Breen was having a sexual relationship
25 with him?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
89
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 MR. BAKER: Objection. Speculation.
2 MR. WALKER: Lacks foundation.
3 MR. DOLAN: She testified at the last
4 deposition that she knew he was having a sexual
5 relationship with him. Foundation was laid in the first
6 deposition.
7 Q. So how tall was [Victim X] at the — to your
8 knowledge, at the time that Walter was having a sexual
9 relationship with him?
10 MR. BAKER: Objection. Speculation.
11 MR. WALKER: Same objection.
12 And Chris, for the record, I don’t know how
13 many months ago that deposition was. I don’t have it in
14 front of me. She doesn’t have that knowledge in mind
15 unless you ask her about it — unless you tell her about
16 it.
17 MR. DOLAN: Q. You still remember saying that
18 Walter had a sexual relationship with [Victim X]; right?
19 A. Yes, I do.
20 Q. You just testified to that about 15 minutes
21 ago?
22 A. Yes. [Victim X] was in our house a great
23 deal.
24 Q. Due to the fact that he was in your house a
25 great deal, how tall was he?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
90
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 MR. BAKER: Objection. Speculation.
2 THE WITNESS: I think he was about five foot,
3 eight.
4 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you think he was big enough
5 to ward off something he didn’t want too?
6 MR. BAKER: Objection. Speculation. Vague,
7 ambiguous. Lacks foundation.
8 MR. WALKER: Same objections. I’ll join.
9 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer.
10 A. I don’t believe I speculated on the matter.
11 Q. Okay. So is size a determining issue in your
12 mind as to whether or not a minor was capable of deciding
13 whether or not they should be having sexual contact with
14 an adult?
15 MR. BAKER: Objection. Speculation.
16 Foundation. Vague, ambiguous.
17 MR. WALKER: Same objections.
18 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer.
19 A. I didn’t do any speculating.
20 Q. I didn’t ask you if you speculated. You
21 indicated earlier that you didn’t worry about your son
22 David because he was six feet tall and could break
23 Mr. Bashlow in half.
24 Do you remember that?
25 A. Yes.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
91
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. So I’m asking you: Is your determination or
2 understanding of when a child was able to make decisions
3 regarding sex with an adult based on the size of that
4 child and ability to physically defend themselves?
5 MR. BAKER: Same objections.
6 MR. WALKER: Same objections.
7 THE WITNESS: That would be one consideration.
8 MR. DOLAN: Q. What other considerations would
9 there be?
10 A. The general maturity of the child in question,
11 the fact whether the adult was the kind of person to be
12 threatening. If the adult was generally a non-threatening
13 person, I think my attitude would have been no harm in
14 asking if he takes no for an answer.
15 Q. Okay. And did you consider Walter to be
16 non-threatening?
17 A. I certainly did.
18 Q. So, did you feel, then, there was no harm in
19 Walter asking young children to have sex with him so long
20 as he would take no for an answer?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. And until — down to what age would that be
23 okay?
24 A. I don’t believe I ever considered the matter
25 much.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
92
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. So —
2 A. It would have come up and been dismissed from
3 my mind in a matter of moments.
4 Q. As you sit here today, do you ever recall
5 forming an opinion what would be a minimum age it would
6 okay for your husband to proposition young boys?
7 A. I never stopped to think about it.
8 Q. You never gave it any thought?
9 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
10 MR. WALKER: Same objection.
11 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever come to a point
12 where you kind of consciously pushed that out of your mind
13 and made a decision not to think about Walter’s
14 interaction with young boys?
15 MR. BAKER: Objection. Vague. Asked and
16 answered. Speculation.
17 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer.
18 MR. WALKER: Same objections.
19 THE WITNESS: I can only say I don’t remember.
20 MR. DOLAN: Q. And my question is a little
21 different. Did you come to a point in time after you were
22 aware of Walter’s interest in young boys that you sort of
23 made a conscious decision not to think about that subject?
24 MR. BAKER: Same objections. Asked and
25 answered as well.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
93
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 MR. WALKER: Same objections.
2 MR. DOLAN: Q. Pardon me?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. Do you have the question in mind?
5 A. You mean did I ever come to such a conclusion?
6 Q. I’ll ask it again.
7 Did you ever come to a point in your life where
8 knowing about your husband’s interest in young men, young
9 boys, that you consciously made a decision that your sort
10 of going to turn your head the other way and not think
11 about it?
12 MR. BAKER: Same objection.
13 MR. WALKER: Same objections.
14 THE WITNESS: No, I did not come to such a
15 decision consciously to turn away from it.
16 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever ask your daughter
17 Moira if Walter had ever propositioned her?
18 A. What?
19 Q. Did you ever ask your daughter Moira if Walter
20 ever propositioned her?
21 A. I don’t think I understand. Are you trying
22 to — seriously asking me if my husband propositioned my
23 daughter? If you are seriously asking that question, I
24 can only say no, she did not say anything about it to me
25 until considerably later, after this was all over with.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
94
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. My question was somewhat different, which was:
2 Did you ever ask your daughter whether Walter had ever
3 propositioned her?
4 A. No, I did not.
5 Q. But you did ask your son?
6 A. Yes; because — because I thought that Walter
7 had a thing about young boys, which is not to be taken as
8 being acceptable in this situation, and therefore I asked.
9 Q. Did you ever ask Patrick whether Walter had
10 ever propositioned Patrick?
11 A. No, I did not.
12 Q. Is there any reason why you felt differently
13 about asking — well, strike that.
14 Can you explain why you asked your son David
15 that question but you didn’t ask your son Patrick that
16 question?
17 A. Yes. Because when we met Walter David was
18 nine. I think when we first met Walter David was nine or
19 ten. When I married him he was 13, and I understood that
20 Walter liked boys that age. Patrick was a baby. Walter
21 saw him born. It never even crossed my mind.
22 Q. Okay. Back in 1964 did you ask Walter whether
23 he was still engaging in sexual acts with [Victim X]?
24 A. I did not.
25 Q. Did you make a conscious decision not to ask
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
95
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 him about his relationship with [Victim X]?
2 A. Yes; because [mother of Victim X] — the subject came
3 up between us. And before you ask, I do not remember how
4 it came up, but somehow or other it came up, and [mother of Victim X]
5 had said that she had no complaint to make about Walter’s
6 relationship with her son.
7 Q. Okay. So at some point you had a discussion
8 with [mother of Victim X] regarding the sexual relationship
9 between Walter and her son; right?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. And did you ask her how she felt about it?
12 A. I think she volunteered that. She said
13 Walter’s influence on her son had been a good one all
14 around.
15 Q. Based upon what she had said to you, did you
16 form any opinion as to whether or not Walter’s
17 relationship with [Victim X] was good for [Victim X]?
18 MR. BAKER: Objection. Speculation. Vague.
19 THE WITNESS: I did not.
20 MR. WALKER: Same objection.
21 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever ask [Victim X]
22 how he felt about the sexual relationship with Walter?
23 A. All I have to say on that point is that once
24 [Victim X] was a big strong boy, and if he had any
25 objections, he could have tied Walter into a bow knot.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
96
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. My question is: Did you ever ask [Victim X] about
2 how he felt about the relationship with Walter?
3 A. No, I did not because, as I say, he was big
4 enough to take care of himself.
5 Q. The discussion with [mother of Victim X], did it happen after
6 you were married to Walter?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. So you knew that the relationship with [Victim X] was
9 still going on after your marriage to Walter?
10 MR. WALKER: Objection. That misstates her
11 testimony.
12 MR. DOLAN: Q. At the time that you had the
13 discussion with [mother of Victim X], did you understand that
14 Walter and [Victim X] were still sexually involved?
15 A. No.
16 Q. Why were you having a discussion with [mother of Victim X]
17 about the subject?
18 A. Oh, you know how women are, they talk about
19 anything that comes up.
20 Q. So at the time that you were having a
21 discussion with [mother of Victim X], did you have any
22 understanding as to whether or not Walter and [Victim X] were
23 still sexually involved?
24 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
25 MR. WALKER: Same objection.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
97
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer it.
2 A. I’m sorry. Could you repeat the question?
3 Q. Sure. At the time that you had the
4 conversation with [mother of Victim X], did you have any
5 understanding as to whether or not Walter and [Victim X] were
6 still sexually involved?
7 MR. BAKER: Same objections.
8 MR. WALKER: Same objections.
9 THE WITNESS: I don’t believe I gave the matter
10 any thought.
11 MR. BAKER: Asked and answered.
12 MR. DOLAN: Q. So, did you ever tell [mother of Victim X]
13 what your opinion was on the relationship between Walter
14 and her son?
15 A. No, I did not.
16 Q. Did you ever form the opinion that it was okay
17 for Walter to have a sexual relationship with [Victim X]
18 when [Victim X] was under the age of 18?
19 A. No, I did not.
20 Q. Prior to marrying Walter, were you ever made
21 aware that Walter had been arrested for lewd and
22 lascivious acts?
23 A. No, I was not.
24 Q. Were you aware that in 1954 he had been
25 arrested as a disturbing person for molesting a child
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
98
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 under the boardwalk?
2 A. No, I did not.
3 Q. I’m going to show you a document that we’re
4 going to mark as plaintiff’s next in order, which was
5 produced by your counsel previously in this litigation.
6 (Plaintiff’s Exhibit 4 was
7 marked for identification.)
8 THE WITNESS: If you’ll pardon my saying so,
9 this whole thing seems useless. The man is dead, and he’s
10 up before a judge much more sterner than any judge in
11 California courts.
12 MR. DOLAN: Q. You’re still with us, that’s
13 why we’re asking questions, because you’re a defendant in
14 this litigation.
15 Do you realize that you’re a defendant in a
16 lawsuit?
17 A. No, I did not. It never occurred to me that
18 anyone could think in those terms.
19 Q. As you sit here today, have you ever been
20 informed that you’re defendant in litigation?
21 A. Well, you’re informing me now.
22 Q. Prior to me informing you, have you ever
23 understood that you’re a defendant in a lawsuit?
24 A. No.
25 MR. WALKER: Objection. That calls for
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
99
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 attorney-client privileged information.
2 MR. DOLAN: Q. Well, I’m just asking prior to
3 my telling you, did you understand that you’re being sued
4 because of the molestation of Ken Smith?
5 MR. WALKER: And only answer —
6 Don’t answer anything that has to do with any
7 discussions that you’ve had with any of your attorneys.
8 MR. DOLAN: Q. Okay. If Elisabeth Waters told
9 you you were being sued or your daughter told you you were
10 being sued or you a saw document that led you to believe,
11 with your name on it, that you were being sued, anything
12 other than your lawyers actually sitting you down and
13 saying, “Hey, you’re being sued.”
14 Prior to sitting down in this room today, did
15 you understand that you were a defendant in a lawsuit?
16 A. Not entirely.
17 Q. Do you understand now that you’re a defendant?
18 A. Yes, I do.
19 Q. Can you answer my question, then? I’m asking
20 you as a defendant in this lawsuit, were you aware of how
21 that document came into your possession that was given to
22 us by your counsel?
23 A. What is this?
24 Q. It’s a two-page document. Just please take a
25 look at it, and I’ll ask you some questions once you’ve
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
100
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 had an opportunity to review it.
2 A. I have no memory of ever having seen that.
3 Q. Okay. Do you have any understanding of where
4 your attorneys got this document they gave to us?
5 A. No.
6 Q. Do you keep a file of Walter’s on Walter in
7 your possession at your home anywhere?
8 A. No.
9 Q. At any point prior to today did you know that
10 Walter Breen had been arrested for molesting children
11 under the boardwalk in 1954 in Atlantic City?
12 A. No, I did not. I didn’t even know he had ever
13 been in Atlantic City.
14 Q. Okay. In your last deposition you indicated
15 that you had not seen [Victim X] since three years following the
16 marriage with Walter Breen.
17 Do you recall that testimony?
18 A. Yes, I do.
19 Q. During the three years that you did see [Victim X]
20 during the marriage, was [Victim X] a frequent visitor at your
21 home?
22 A. Yes, he was.
23 Q. Okay. To your knowledge, was he engaging in
24 sexual activity with Walter during the three years that he
25 was a visitor at your home?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
101
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. I have no idea.
2 Q. Did you ever so inquire knowing that Walter had
3 previously had a sexual relationship with [Victim X]?
4 A. I did not.
5 Q. Did you ever do anything to protect [Victim X]
6 from any type of sexual contact with Walter Breen
7 during the three years that he was a guest in your home
8 following your marriage?
9 A. Oh, please. The idea of me protecting little
10 [Victim X], good heavens.
11 MR. BAKER: Objection. Lacks foundation as
12 well as argumentative.
13 MR. WALKER: I’ll join in those objections.
14 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever do anything —
15 I’ll ask the question again because I would
16 like an answer to the question.
17 Did you ever do anything to protect [Victim X]
18 from sexual contact with your husband during the
19 three years following your marriage that you knew [Victim X]
20 was around your home?
21 A. It never occurred to.
22 MR. BAKER: Same objections.
23 MR. WALKER: Same objections.
24 MR. DOLAN: Q. It never occurred to you is
25 your answer, that it was necessary?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
102
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 MR. BAKER: Same objections.
2 MR. DOLAN: Q. You never asked [Victim X] if it was
3 okay with him; right?
4 A. I never asked [Victim X] because I knew perfectly
5 well that if anything was wrong he could come to me. We
6 were on terms that — I mean, he was in my house. He was
7 getting milk from my refrigerator. He was eating at our
8 table. If anything had been wrong, he would have come to
9 me and said, Marion, there is something wrong. I’m quite
10 sure he would have.
11 Q. So, as long as he didn’t come to you and say,
12 Marion, there is something wrong, you felt no need to
13 inquire?
14 A. No.
15 MR. BAKER: Objection. Argumentative.
16 MR. WALKER: I’ll join in that.
17 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever —
18 Did it ever bother you that your husband might
19 be sleeping with this boy?
20 MR. BAKER: Objection. Argumentative. Lacks
21 foundation.
22 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer.
23 MR. BAKER: Same objections.
24 THE WITNESS: I never gave it any thought.
25 MR. DOLAN: Q. Pardon?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
103
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. I never gave it any thought. At that time I
2 was newly married to my husband. I was pregnant, and I
3 was very happy with him.
4 MR. WALKER: You can just let him ask the
5 questions, and then you can give the answers, but you
6 don’t have to volunteer anything.
7 THE WITNESS: Okay.
8 MR. DOLAN: Q. During those three years did
9 Walter and you have any other boys under the age of 18 in
10 the home?
11 A. Not to my knowledge.
12 Q. Did you ever talk to Walter about whether or
13 not he was still having sex with [Victim X] after your marriage?
14 MR. BAKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
15 MR. WALKER: Same objection.
16 MR. DOLAN: Q. Go ahead.
17 A. I did not.
18 Q. Did you ever say to Walter, I don’t want you to
19 be having sex with anybody else now that we’re married?
20 MR. BAKER: Objection. Argumentative.
21 MR. WALKER: I’ll join.
22 THE WITNESS: I did not.
23 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever say anything to
24 Walter about, you know, Walter you need to be careful.
25 This might be illegal?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
104
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 MR. BAKER: Objection. Argumentative.
2 MR. WALKER: Same objection.
3 THE WITNESS: It never occurred to me.
4 MR. DOLAN: Q. Did you ever discuss with
5 Walter the legality or illegality of having sex with boys
6 under the age of 18?
7 A. I did not.
8 Q. Did you ever discuss it with anybody prior to
9 Ken Smith’s molestation being made known to you?
10 A. Not —
11 Yes.
12 Q. Okay. Who Did you discuss that with?
13 A. With my daughter, Moira.
14 Q. When did you discuss it with Moira?
15 A. I think it was —
16 It was shortly before her marriage.
17 Q. Before what?
18 A. Before her marriage.
19 Q. Okay. And what was the reason that you and
20 Moira discussed that?
21 A. She made an allegation that her father had
22 molested her.
23 Q. Was that before or after Ken Smith’s
24 molestation was reported to the police?
25 A. I have no idea.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
105
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. Do you know if your daughter was married before
2 or after Ken Smith’s molestation was reported to the
3 police?
4 A. I thought I did, but I’m sure I don’t.
5 Q. Are you still focused on the questions? Are
6 you having any difficulty answering now? Are you
7 mentally — are you still here in time and space?
8 A. Yes. I’m trying to make up a time line in my
9 mind.
10 Q. Okay. Very good.
11 Other than your discussion with Moira prior to
12 her marriage regarding the legality or illegality of
13 Walter’s contact with minor children, did you ever discuss
14 that topic with anyone else?
15 A. I can’t think of anyone.
16 Q. When you and Walter were thinking about
17 adopting [Johnny Doe 1], did you ever have a discussion
with
18 Walter saying, Walter, if we adopt [Johnny Doe 1] you
can’t have
19 sex with him?
20 A. Yes, I did.
21 Q. Okay. Tell me about that.
22 A. I just told him flat out that if we adopted
23 [Johnny Doe 1] he would be our son and nothing else.
That it was
24 not to be a boyfriend or anything of that sort.
25 Q. At that point did you have any concerns that
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
106
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Walter might be having sex with [Johnny Doe 1] such that
it caused
2 you to tell Walter that?
3 A. I did not. I was just sort of vaguely thinking
4 back on our whole background.
5 Q. And when you say your “whole background,” what
6 do you mean by that?
7 A. Of everything that had happened since I had
8 first met Walter and everything everyone else had said
9 about him.
10 Q. Now, you said that he would be your son and
11 nothing else. Do you think that would put him in a
12 different category than other young boys?
13 MR. BAKER: Objection. Argumentative.
14 MR. WALKER: I’ll join in that. And vague and
15 ambiguous.
16 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer it.
17 A. I don’t believe that I formulated it in any
18 way.
19 Q. What did you mean by your statement to Walter
20 that he would be our son and nothing else?
21 A. That if he had any idea in his mind that the
22 boy might be a subject for his — his sexual interests, he
23 should put that right out of his mind right away.
24 Q. Okay. And why would —
25 A. That if he ever had such an idea, and I wasn’t
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
107
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 accusing him of it, that he should not continue thinking
2 that way.
3 Q. All right. And did you think that —
4 Was that solely because he was going to be
5 adopted by you?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. So if he wasn’t to be adopted by you, then you
8 would not have had this conversation with Walter about
9 this boy being a part of his sexual interests?
10 MR. BAKER: Objection.
11 MR. WALKER: Objection. That lacks foundation.
12 MR. BAKER: Speculation.
13 MR. WALKER: Speculation.
14 MR. DOLAN: Q. You can answer it.
15 A. I didn’t speculate on my husband’s affairs. We
16 were no longer living together at that time, and I paid
17 very little attention to what was going on.
18 Q. Okay. You weren’t living together. Where was
19 Walter living at that time?
20 A. He was living a couple of doors up the street.
21 Q. In the gold fishbowl?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. So at the time that he was living in the gold
24 fishbowl and you were aware that [Johnny Doe 1] might
be
25 adopted by you, you told Walter that he could not be a
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
108
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 subject of Walter’s sexual affection; is that correct?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. And did you understand that [Johnny Doe 1] might be
4 spending time at that other premises where Walter was
5 living?
6 A. Yes, I did.
7 Q. Okay. And did you feel that you had some
8 responsibility to [Johnny Doe 1] to tell Walter —
9 A. Yes. That if we had adopted [Johnny Doe 1], he would
10 have been our son.
11 Q. So, did you feel you had some responsibility to
12 [Johnny Doe 1] to tell Walter no sex with [Johnny
Doe 1]?
13 A. Yes. I laid down the law very firmly.
14 Q. All right.
15 A. It was one of the reasons we — we eventually
16 split up.
17 Q. What do you mean by that?
18 A. He was very upset with me. He said I didn’t
19 trust him, and, of course, I didn’t.
20 Q. So you didn’t trust Walter around young boys at
21 that time, did you?
22 A. At that point, no.
23 Q. And do you know approximately what year that
24 was?
25 A. I am afraid I couldn’t tell you.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
109
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. Can you give me an estimate or approximation?
2 A. I think I began to think differently of him
3 about — about 1975 or ‘6.
4 Q. Okay. So sometime —
5 Was it sometime around then that [Johnny Doe 1]
6 came along?
7 A. I think it was after that.
8 Q. Approximately how long after that?
9 A. I couldn’t tell you.
10 Q. Can you give me an estimate or an
11 approximation, was it before 1980, between ’80 and ’85,
12 anything you can do to help me?
13 A. It might have been.
14 Q. Might have been which?
16 I saw [Johnny Doe 1] a few weeks ago.
17 Q. Okay. So you were concerned that Walter might
18 have some inappropriate sexual relationship with [Johnny
Doe 1]
19 over at the other house?
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. And you told him that that was completely
22 prohibited; right?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. And how old did you understand [Johnny Doe 1] to be
at
25 that time?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
110
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. I thought he was about 12 or 13.
2 Q. And how big was [Johnny Doe 1]?
3 A. He was small and fragile.
4 Q. So, did you feel you had a responsibility at
5 that time to protect [Johnny Doe 1] from Walter?
6 A. Yes, I did. More than anybody else I felt very
7 protective toward [Johnny Doe 1].
8 Q. And what was — made you feel that more than
9 anybody else you had a responsibility to [Johnny Doe 1]?
10 A. Well, when he was around he’d come sit on my
11 lap sometimes and things like that, so I developed a
12 certain feeling that he didn’t have any other family and
13 that I’d take care of him.
14 Q. Did Walter ever refuse to agree to your
15 condition that he not have sex with [Johnny Doe 1]?
16 A. He didn’t. No, he didn’t.
17 Q. Did he ever agree to it?
18 A. I don’t remember.
19 I don’t think he said in so many words no, I
20 will not have sex with [Johnny Doe 1]. I think he said
something
21 like, You don’t have to worry about that or something.
22 Q. Was this topic of sex with [Johnny Doe 1] at all one
of
23 the reasons why [Johnny Doe 1] was never adopted?
24 A. Not that I know of.
25 Q. What was your understanding as to the reason
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
111
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 why [Johnny Doe 1] wasn’t adopted?
2 A. I believe that his — his father was in prison,
3 wanted to maintain a relationship with him and didn’t want
4 him adopted.
5 Q. Were you ever interviewed by the people at CPS
6 regarding the adoption?
7 A. Yes, I was.
8 We went and attended a couple of classes on
9 adoption.
10 Q. Did they ever ask you whether either of you had
11 ever had any problems with sex with minors?
12 A. The question did not come up. Of that I am
13 perfectly sure.
14 Q. What makes you say you’re perfectly sure of
15 that?
16 A. Because I think I would have remembered that.
17 Q. Did you ever inform them that Walter had had a
18 sexual relationship with [Victim X]?
19 A. No, I did not.
20 Q. Did you ever tell them that you were concerned
21 about Walter perhaps having a sexual relationship with
22 [Johnny Doe 1]?
23 A. No, I did not.
24 Q. Why didn’t you?
25 A. I think the only answer I can make to that is
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
112
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 that it’s quite obvious that you have never been in love.
2 Q. Can you explain that further? I don’t
3 understand your answer.
4 A. Simply that the subject did not come up even in
5 my mind. It came up briefly, and I mentioned it, and that
6 was the end of it.
7 Q. So the subject did come up in your mind enough
8 for you to raise it Walter; correct?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. But you didn’t raise it with the child
11 protective authorities?
12 A. No.
13 Q. And you’re saying that’s because of your love
14 for Walter?
15 A. I don’t know if by then it was love or just a
16 general sense of protectiveness.
17 Q. So, was you’re not telling CPS an effort to
18 protect Walter?
19 A. I suspect it must have been.
20 Q. As you sit here today, do you believe that
21 you’re not telling CPS was in an effort to protect Walter?
22 MR. WALKER: Objection. Asked and answered.
23 MR. DOLAN: Q. You may answer it.
24 A. I suspect it must have been.
25 Q. Okay. How are you doing? You need a break?
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
113
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 A. No. I’m all right.
2 Q. Are there any other boys that you told Walter
3 you’re not to have sex with that boy?
4 A. Well, Moira at one time complained that Walter
5 was coming on to one of her boyfriends.
6 Q. Okay.
7 A. And I went up to Walter’s house and I said,
8 “Look, this is not a good thing to do.”
9 Q. Okay. Which boyfriend was that; do you
10 remember?
11 A. I think his name was [Johnny Doe 4] something.
12 Q. [Johnny Doe 4]?
13 A. It could have been.
14 Q. Okay. Did Moira ever —
15 So Moira said to you she was afraid that Walter
16 might be trying to have sex with [Johnny Doe 4]?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. Okay. Approximately when was this?
19 A. I don’t remember the date. I think at that
20 time it was — she was at University of California then.
21 Q. How old did you understand [Johnny Doe 4] to be?
22 A. I thought he was 17 or 18.
23 Q. Did you ever ask him, [Johnny Doe 4], about what
24 was going on?
25 A. No, I didn’t. But I mean, the two of them were
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
114
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 going around together, and he looked to be 18 or 19.
2 Q. And did you tell Walter not to have sex with
3 [Johnny Doe 4]?
4 A. I just said that Moira would not approve.
5 Q. So it was based upon Moira being unhappy with
6 the situation?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. Did you ever tell Walter when he was living in
9 the gold fishbowl that he was not to have sex with minors
10 in that home?
11 A. I never mentioned the matter.
12 Q. You were the landlord there, weren’t you?
13 A. I owned the house.
14 Q. Did you lease it to Walter?
15 A. No. I let him live in it because he needed a
16 place to live.
17 Q. So it’s your testimony that you never leased it
18 to him?
19 A. Not formally, no.
20 MR. DOLAN: Okay. Let’s mark this as
21 plaintiff’s next in order.
22 (Plaintiff’s Exhibit 5 was
23 marked for identification.)
24 MR. DOLAN: It’s already been marked as
25 Plaintiff’s 3 to Elisabeth Water’s deposition, but we’ll
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
115
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 just mark it for this one too.
2 Q. See your signature on this document?
3 A. Oh, yes.
4 Q. Okay. What’s the date of that document at the
5 top?
6 A. February ’94.
7 Q. Actually, it says ’86, doesn’t it?
8 A. I can’t tell.
9 Yes, I guess it does say ’86.
10 Q. Having seen this document, do you want to
11 change your testimony as to whether or not you formally
12 leased that premise to Walter Breen?
13 A. I can only think that it’s something that
14 somebody stuck in front of me and said, sign this, and I
15 saw Elisabeth’s name was already on it and signed it. I
16 was not aware of what it was.
17 Q. Prior to 1986 did you know that Walter Breen
18 had had sex with minor boys?
19 A. Yes. I have said that on several occasions
20 now.
21 Q. And you rented that place to him anyways;
22 right?
23 A. Well, he needed a place to live.
24 Q. Okay.
25 A. What was I supposed to do, throw him out in the
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
116
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 street?
2 Q. I’ll withhold my comments.
3 A. Well, I —
4 Q. Did you undertake any activity to ensure that
5 Walter Breen would not molest young boys at this property
6 that you rented to him?
7 A. As I say, at the time [Johnny Doe 1] was there. I
told
8 him [Johnny Doe 1] was off limits, and I told him
[Johnny Doe 4] was off
9 limits.
10 Q. Okay. But the other ones weren’t off limits?
11 A. I never knew there were any others there.
12 Q. Did you ever tell him it would be off limits to
13 molest young boys on your property?
14 A. In those words, no.
15 Q. Did you ever tell him that he was not to have
16 young boys on your property?
17 A. I did not tell him that in those words, no.
18 Q. Did you know that he had young boys on your
19 property?
20 A. I did not.
21 Q. You knew that he had [Johnny Doe 1] there?
22 A. Yes. Well, that was different. [Johnny Doe 1] was
23 there because of both of us.
24 Q. You knew he had [Victim X] there; right?
25 A. No; [Victim X] never came to that place —
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
117
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. Okay.
2 A. — to the best of my knowledge and belief.
3 Q. You knew he had Ken Smith there, didn’t you?
4 A. I don’t know who Ken Smith is or who he was. I
5 wouldn’t know Ken Smith from — well, I would know
6 President Reagan because I saw him on T.V., so I can’t say
7 I wouldn’t know him from President Reagan.
8 Q. Do you recall telling the police you met Ken
9 Smith when Walter brought him around?
10 A. Yes, I do. I mean, sometime after he had been
11 living in the gold fishbowl for quite awhile.
12 Q. You knew that he had Ken Smith over there;
13 right?
14 A. Well, he came in one day with Ken Smith, so I
15 assumed it.
16 Q. So you assumed at some point after Walter moved
17 into the gold fishbowl and you rented it to Walter that
18 Walter had Ken Smith over there; right?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Did you ever tell Walter, You can’t molest Ken
21 Smith over there?
22 A. I didn’t know him from Adam or Fox.
23 Q. But you met him and knew Walter had him over
24 there and —
25 A. Oh, yes.
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
118
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 Q. Did you ever tell Walter, Ken Smith is off
2 limits?
3 A. It never occurred to me. I think what I
4 probably thought was that was up to Ken Smith to tell him
5 if he didn’t want to.
6 Q. So at that point you believed it was up to Ken
7 Smith to tell him if he didn’t want to have sex with
8 Walter?
9 A. Yes.
10 MR. DOLAN: Can we take a couple-second break?
11 We’re getting pretty close to our hour, but I want to take
12 a two-minute break. Just two minutes.
13 MR. WALKER: Okay. Well, I mean, we have about
14 two minutes left in the deposition.
15 MR. DOLAN: Actually, my stopwatch shows that I
16 have about seven minutes left, and I hope you’ll give me
17 two minutes’ credit. And I’m giving you time off with my
18 client’s deposition. I mean, I wouldn’t jam you on two
19 minutes here. I’m trying to be polite.
20 (Whereupon, the deposition adjourned at 12:24
21 p.m.)
22
23
24
25 MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
119
DEPOSITION OF MARION ZIMMER BRADLEY, 12/14/98
1 I, the undersigned, hereby certify that the
2 witness in the foregoing deposition was, by me, duly sworn
3 to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the
4 truth in the within-entitled cause.
5
6 That said deposition was taken in shorthand by
7 me, a Certified Shorthand Reporter and a disinterested
8 person, at the time and place therein stated, and that the
9 testimony of said witness was thereafter reduced to
10 typewriting, by computer, under my direction and
11 supervision.
12
13 I further certify that I am not of counsel or
14 attorney for either or any of the parties of the said
15 deposition, nor in any way interested in the event of this
16 cause, and that I am not related to any of the parties
17 thereto.
18
19 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand,
20 this 29th day of December 1998.
21
22
23
24 ________________________
Janine P. Branco
25 CSR #10372
SHALLENBERGER REPORTING SERVICES – (415) 771-1988
120
Note: This page originally appeared at http://sff.net/people/stephen.goldin/mzb/MZB_Depos_1+2.html, but that subsite is permanently offline. Stephen Goldin’s new site is here, but it does not contain the MZB tree (that I found). Note: I didn’t edit the text of this page, even to correct typos, except to add a header where the second deposition starts so it could be jumped to.